Re:Implementing a Type-safe printf in Rust
by signa11 on Friday August 14, 2020 @06:38AM
(#24156190)
> The issue with templates is that you can’t really type check them at the point of definition. Instead they need to be checked each time the template is used.
> This can make compilation slow but it can also make template writing very hard because a bug might only appear when a template is instantiated with certain types.
yup. templates are 'compiled' in 2 phases as follows:
- without instantiation at definition time, the code itself is checked for correctness, completely ignoring the template parameters.
- at instantiation time, the code is checked again to ensure that all parts depending on template parameters are valid.
the 2-phase translation breaks canonical notions about compile+link, where declarations of function is sufficient to compile its use...
> This can make compilation slow but it can also make template writing very hard because a bug might only appear when a template is instantiated with certain types.
yup. templates are 'compiled' in 2 phases as follows:
- without instantiation at definition time, the code itself is checked for correctness, completely ignoring the template parameters.
- at instantiation time, the code is checked again to ensure that all parts depending on template parameters are valid.
the 2-phase translation breaks canonical notions about compile+link, where declarations of function is sufficient to compile its use...