Re:Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
by __d on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:37PM
(#24181962)
I agree that the principle is interesting.
The music/video industry asserts that you're not allowed to play/show some media item that you've bought. Amazon doesn't allow you to resell or bequeath Kindle books. Caterpillar doesn't let you repair your own tractor.
The first sale doctrine was established in a very different time.
Either we do, in which case what Apple is doing in perfectly reasonable, as is Walmart selling fridges that explode when you put someone else's milk in them ("It's in the contract!"), or it isn't.
Things like the first sale doctrine give an insight into past legal thinking suggesting the latter. But it's far from simple to discern by just looking at the law.