Re:WSJ: "India Graduates Millions But Too Few Are Fit to Hir...
by sethg on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @09:04AM
(#2414913)
If I recall correctly, the fire department in question was afraid that if it promoted strictly based on the test, then at least one black firefighter who hadn’t been promoted would sue, and the department didn’t want to defend the test in court. So they tried to dodge the problem by bailing on the test, and then got sued from the other direction.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:WSJ: "India Graduates Millions But Too Few Are Fit to Hir...
by yummyfajitas on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @09:23AM
(#2414973)
That fear was quite legitimate.
After Ricci was decided, a black firefighter sued the city over the test [1]. His theory was that weighting promotions via 60% objective written test/40% subjective oral test was racist since it had a disparate impact on blacks. He lost.
http://www.nhregister.com/articles/2010/04/22/news/aa3_nebri...
[1] I believe he lacked standing before the supreme court decision, since he suffered no harm.
Re:WSJ: "India Graduates Millions But Too Few Are Fit to Hir...
by sethg on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @09:55AM
(#2415068)
Well, yeah, it’s a legitimate fear, but they should have handled that fear by being ready to defend their testing system in court before the tests were administered, and having the courage of their convictions.
Re:WSJ: "India Graduates Millions But Too Few Are Fit to Hir...
by andrewflnr on Wednesday April 06, 2011 @11:37AM
(#2415487)
Unfortunately, being firm in your convictions or even being right is not always enough to win in court.