News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jefft255 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:11PM (#24148088)
I disagree. I like Apple products, own an iPhone and iPad, but I wish I could run any code on it because they are my devices. Having a streamlined experience overall shouldn’t prevent me from installing an emulator, and shouldn’t trap businesses into paying ridiculous fees. Im hesitating buying a Mac as my next computer because of their locked down attitude, which could spill to MacOS (already has to some degree).
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by mike_d on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:20PM (#24148282)
> I wish I could run any code on it

But by extension that means any bad guy can run any unsigned code on it as well.

Look at the prevalence of Android malware to iOS. The latter basically doesn't exist outside of well funded nation states.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jefft255 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:29PM (#24148473)
Unless Apple really screws up, that malware would have to be downloaded and installed by me. If I "flip a switch" and enable that option, that's on me. PCs have always been like this and no one bats an eye. I'd be willing to accept that risk; hey, Apple could make flipping that switch really freaking difficult if they wanted too, I wouldn't mind. Just as long as I have the option.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by dijit on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:04PM (#24149119)
My girlfriend has an iPhone and an android phone. She is 29, she has accidentally installed malware from the play store, multiple times.

Anecdote yes, but the fact it happened in my house and more than once opened my eyes significantly to the problem.

My grandparents have no chance if my girlfriend gets got.

You and I live in a microcosm, most people on this site have a very finely tuned bullshit filter. Don’t assume everyone does, even the young.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by asddubs on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:18PM (#24149366)
even so, there's no reason a filtering of software for anti-malware purposes must be conflated with the private entity also arbitrarily deciding what software is and isn't allowed. they could do one without the other
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by dijit on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:29PM (#24149565)
What you said makes no sense whatsoever.

A platform that filters will remove things, unless your speaking from the pulpit of “the algorithm”.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by asddubs on Thursday August 13, 2020 @07:44PM (#24151290)
yes but filtering malicious code and filtering by arbitrary criteria are not the same thing.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by surfpel on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:43PM (#24148763)
There are many tech illiterate people in this world, and many who would be easy prey to someone pulling a scam, getting them to flip that switch.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by ac29 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:10PM (#24149246)
Life has risks - you could fall off a ladder and injure yourself, but we dont outlaw them because as a society we recognize that they are also useful tools.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by surfpel on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:04PM (#24151522)
> Life has risks - you could fall off a ladder and injure yourself

Great analogy actually. Ladders are dangerous, yes - but we don’t make them necessary to daily life and they’re certainly not something most people interact with

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jefft255 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:52PM (#24148917)
My answer to that is: what about PCs? Of course you're right, and I'm right too (I'd like to think ahah). This is freedom at the cost of security; this trade-off, as in real life, has no simple solution. I certainly don't pretend to have the answer here.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by baddox on Thursday August 13, 2020 @06:44PM (#24150535)
> Unless Apple really screws up, that malware would have to be downloaded and installed by me. If I "flip a switch" and enable that option, that's on me.

The fact that Apple does not have this attitude is why their products are better for customers than alternatives that do have this attitude. A customer isn't any happier with a malware-ridden device if it got that way because they were tricked into clicking a fake software update button.

> PCs have always been like this and no one bats an eye.

Yes, lots of people bat eyes. As a very on-the-nose examples, lots of people buy Macs, for instance, because of their reputation for having less malware (that might be outdated now, but was certainly true for a large portion of the last 20 years). Malware has been a major problem for customers on PCs and Android phones for a long time. The fact that the problem has existed for a long time doesn't mean it's not a big problem.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by orangecat on Thursday August 13, 2020 @10:08PM (#24152384)
The fact that Apple does not have this attitude is why their products are better for customers than alternatives that do have this attitude.

Macs allow you to install software from anywhere. Which is bad and Apple should disallow it, right?

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by baddox on Thursday August 13, 2020 @11:16PM (#24152877)
There is a long tradition of Mac customers expecting that ability, and Apple has explicitly said they recognize that desire in the market and is not removing the ability. That said, they have added some extra warnings and confirmation steps in order to run unsigned software, and some people have even complained about that.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by munk-a on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:25PM (#24148393)
Apple does an extremely poor job of software inspection - they have API limiters that are quite effective at shutting down a lot of the malicious-to-device software people might write but privacy concerns are impossible for them to cover. Depending on how you define unsigned code your statement is either quite correct or extremely inaccurate and I think issues like privacy and data tracking are, honestly, more noticeable and impactful to the average non-techy user than your phone being part of a botnet.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by mike_d on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:31PM (#24148520)
"Hide my Email for Sign in", killing advertising identifiers, preventing cross app tracking, etc. are all things that can only exist on a platform where code is signed and sandboxed.

Is Apple's app store vetting or API restrictions perfect? No, of course not. But it is a million times better than any other platform.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by Mindwipe on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:29PM (#24148472)
The former basically doesn't exist in Western nations either, so I'm not sure what the point is here.

A well designed permissions system means what code runs is up to the user.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by mike_d on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:41PM (#24148724)
In 2019 Kaspersky Labs identified over 3 million unique Android malware samples. iOS malware is so rare AV companies usually issue press releases about finding them (like LightSpy).

The reason you might not know about Xerxes, SMSreg, Cerberus, LokiBot, BlackRock, FunkyBot, UpDroid, etc. is because another Android malware family isn't newsworthy.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by dogma1138 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:51PM (#24148913)
You can run any code on it already as a developer.
Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by g_p on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:34PM (#24148585)
It seems to me the obvious solution is to extend the "parental controls" install permission feature, and add an optional restriction API for "sideload apps" (like on Android). This would handle the "I want a locked down device" scenario for MDM and parental controls users.

Those who want an unrestricted device could enable sideloading (which would permit non-apple-notarized apps to be installed), and permit non-expiring developer self-signed apps. Then the free market could go ahead and develop "stores" and alternative ecosystems.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jki275 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:32PM (#24148543)
You can run pretty much any code on your iPad and iPhone that you want. You do need to pay your 99 bucks or so for a dev account, but you can run anything you can build for your iOS devices that way.

There is no "locked down attitude" with macOS, macOS is as open as ever. You can easily turn off all the malware protection if you want to do that. Many devs do.

The argument here isn't about you running any code you want. The argument is about access to the App Store and forcing Apple to allow anyone to distribute anything. That's something I don't want. I want Apple to distribute high quality apps that I can generally trust not to be riddled with malware, unlike their competitors. Apple has built a high value App Store, and devs want to change that to suit their wishes, and in so doing would turn it into the thing it has managed to keep away from since its beginning.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jefft255 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:44PM (#24148774)
I think your argument is invalid, because i.e. Epic wouldn't want to share a buildable XCode project of Fortnite with you. The 99$ fee is also unreasonable IMHO.

Also, building complex applications is far from non-trivial; it's typical for me to spend a few hours fiddling with dependencies to get some complicated code running.

As for MacOS, yes on the software side things are still open, but on the hardware side things are closing up (for example, mandatory unbreakable encryption which can make data recovery impossible; I don't have a big problem with that however). Plus I've got no idea how long that will lasts since Apple does whatever it wants.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by dmurray on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:07PM (#24149185)
> I think your argument is invalid, because i.e. Epic wouldn't want to share a buildable XCode project of Fortnite with you.

They could share an installer that downloads and copies their binaries. Not too different from what many game publishers do on PC.

I'm not sure whether the main barrier to people doing this is the $99/year fee, or the friction associated with setting up a developer account, or the perceived (and real) risk of getting malware if customers made a habit of doing this.

But an iPhone in the US already costs $1000 over say 5 years, plus several hundred per year in carrier costs. I could entertain an argument that an extra $99/year to have an effectively unlocked device is not exorbitant or anticompetitive. If you think it is...would you still think so at $49? Or $9? The revenue Apple get from that must be insignificant compared to the app store.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by jki275 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @05:10PM (#24149249)
Right - epic isn’t going to give you the source.

But you can run anything you can build.

Building a good Xcode project is as simple as pushing the “open in Xcode” button on github and pushing build. Obviously not all projects are that nice.

Re:Epic Games has filed legal papers in response to Apple [pdf] by fomine3 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @08:48PM (#24151874)
You'll fine with keep disabled the 3rd party store option.