News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by clement_b on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:33AM (#24130451)
What I find interesting, is that those who were betting on Brexit were probably doing so thinking it might be a little bit tough in the short term believing the UK will end up being stronger in the end.

With such a massive recession already happening, and talks around Brexit going nowhere, they are really not going to have a nice next 5/10 years.

I have just left the UK, several Europeans I know, working in tech, are doing the same. Not data backed, just personal experience. Maybe this is going to be even tougher than expected. Hopefully not.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by thewarrior on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:08AM (#24130726)
I recently saw a graph that shocked me. Basically the UKs per capita GDP has been constant since 2008 ! If you smooth out the ups and downs it’s just gone sideways.

The UK is a nation that is stagnating and this one two punch could be what pushes it into a decline.

Brexit has become something of a religious movement. Things will magically get better after brexit but first you need suffer for your past sins before you get to the promised land. It’s not at all clear how this will happen but the less possible it looks the stronger the faithful become.

People like me who try to dissuade people from Brexit try to paint a picture of doom and chaos. The UK will be “fine” but it will fall in the League of Nations to the influence of an Italy or a Spain and in the long term this can be hard to swallow for people used to the glories of empire.

This is also one of the most egregious cases of the older generation screwing over the futures of a younger generation by taking away huge opportunities from them. The enormity of this will take a decade to sink in. You’re going to see a lot of pissed off zoomers in 10 years who’ll work to reverse all of this anyway.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by thu2111 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:23PM (#24135737)
See, this is what annoys people about the anti-Brexit brigade.

There are two very important facts you're not giving people here. Firstly, yes, the UK has had stagnant GDP per capita since 2008. So has Germany, so has France. So has Switzerland, since 2010. Clearly, this is not a UK specific issue.

The exceptions? America and ... Ireland. That's tech companies. They are big enough to move per capita GDP by themselves.

The second rather important fact is that the UK is still a part of the EU today for all intents and purposes. It still has to pay and is still a part of all the systems. What you're saying is that as part of the EU the UK, and additionally other major European economies, have seen 12 years of economic stagnation.

You know what one of the top arguments for Brexit was? The EU is a stagnant economy, structurally so, and it's getting worse. If we leave we can be more dynamic and fix that problem.

hard to swallow for people used to the glories of empire.

This is such a bizarre, insulting and ridiculous talking point. Remainers bring it up repeatedly but I've never encountered someone who supports Brexit who talks about the British Empire. It doesn't happen. It's a fantasy.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by thewarrior on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:39PM (#24135920)
Okay let’s take this one by one :

Germany’s per capita GDP has also stagnated: Thats because you chose the date as 2010. I was comparing to the 2008 peak and in comparison UK has gone down but Germany is up. The UK does somewhat worse than the others.

Now on top of this stagnation Brexit will make it worse because you will lose the vast majority of your trading advantages. There’s no magical resurgence that’s going to happen.

As for empire nostalgia as someone who moved from a colony it’s actually quite evident in the politics here. That there is some magic sauce in this tiny island which will allow it to somehow return to glory all by itself.

A poll by YouGov showed that 27 % of Britons want Britain to still have an empire. Closely followed by Netherlands at 26 % and France at 17 %. So these people exist. They are not a fantasy and there’s polling data to show it.

My point wasn’t that they vote for brexit because of the empire. But it feeds into a sense of exceptionalism and megalomania that goes into decisions like Brexit which the vast majority of international observers of the situation agree is a very foolish decision.

It’s just like voting for Trump. Everyone outside the US could plainly see the idiocy and hordes of people would descend to defend it while every passing day exposes it for the foolishness it was. Same will be the case here.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by thu2111 on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:44AM (#24155445)
The UK is a financial centre, obviously if you pick as your start date a financial bubble it will look different.

But 10 years have passed. You were misleading people when you tried to imply that Brexit had something to do with GDP per capita statistics. It clearly doesn't. And many argue it's the other way around: the EU is the cause of the stagnation.

As for empire nostalgia as someone who moved from a colony it’s actually quite evident in the politics here

Evident in the politics? If it's evident then evidence it. You're seeing what you want to see: I can't recall any politicians talking about Empire. It never comes up. It's not even taught in school. The "people used to the glories of the empire" as you put it are virtually all dead. Nobody cares.

As for polls, they routinely show all kinds of garbage when pollsters ask questions that don't matter. For example 4% Americans believe the Earth is run by a conspiracy of lizards, and 7% aren't sure:

https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/12/noisy-poll-results-and...

If some random person wasted my time by asking me if I'd like Britain to still have an empire, I'd probably say, sure why not? Empires have their benefits. Ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer. That doesn't mean I'd think about it even one iota the rest of the time. Heck there was an HN thread just a few days ago about colonialism, that was the first time I'd seen it come up in years.

it feeds into a sense of exceptionalism and megalomania

The majority of the British voting population are not megalomaniacs. Listen to yourself. The very concept is absurd.

Anyway, if you're really convinced the UK is filled with delusional imperialist megalomaniacs, why not leave? You clearly have no respect for the country.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by danjac on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:55AM (#24131555)
Italy or Spain is a best-case scenario. Looking at recent polls in Scotland - where support for the Union has collapsed among the under 50s - the UK will be lucky to still be a single country in 10 or 15 years' time.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by thewarrior on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:03AM (#24131630)
Scottish exit is a very difficult idea to implement. Tories won’t allow another referendum at any cost. I feel for them and hope they can exit and rejoin EU.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by danjac on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:52AM (#24130598)
Data shows that even British natives are leaving in higher numbers:

https://apnews.com/2be77e0ade49893bfefe508eb15c2d56

I suspect the government will use the pandemic as cover for all the failures of Brexit, and they will get away with it given the dire state of British traditional and social media. You're better off out of it.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by joelbluminator on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:59AM (#24130660)
It's hard to say what will happen. It's not like the EU project is a stable, sure-win project. The EU could potentially collapse. Even if it doesn't a Euro devaluation against other currencies (not necessarily USD) may happen because the south needs to be bailed out. Add to that stagnant growth, rising populism, backlash against immigration etc etc.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by kristiandupont on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:10AM (#24130750)
After the UK voted for Brexit I became interested in what treaties and trade deals are and how they are made. It turns out to be much more complex than I had imagined. The amount of legal and diplomatic work that the UK is facing is unfathomable. I can't see any scenario where this is not going to be extremely expensive.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by maxehmookau on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:40AM (#24130978)
> those who were betting on Brexit were probably doing so thinking it might be a little bit tough

No. Nobody who voted for Brexit was thinking logically or clearly at all. Anybody can dismiss this as a political opinion, but not a single person who supported brexit did so for anything other than :

* Flag-waving nationalism. * Financial self-interest from a long-term reduction in EU standards. * Perceived (but incorrect) financial self-interest.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by lucozade on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @10:42AM (#24132484)
Nonsense. I think Brexit was a particularly stupid idea but I've spoken to a number of people who voted for Brexit and every one had a perfectly sound reason that I happen to disagree with or don't consider an important issue. Interestingly (to me), not one of them voted for financial reasons.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by maxehmookau on Thursday August 13, 2020 @04:45AM (#24141225)
> a perfectly sound reason

Please, do elaborate.

Because I'm yet to hear a sensible reason for Brexit that doesn't end up with general pearl-clutching about soverignity or can stand up to any sort of logical argument.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by callamdelaney on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:52AM (#24130596)
> as coronavirus lockdown measures pushed the country officially into recession.

This is nothing to do with brexit.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by akmarinov on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:56AM (#24130638)
Yep, this is the first punch from the Corona and the second punch will be beginning of next year when they end up with no deal.

The sad thing is that everyone will say that Brexit went through great with no issues, it's the Coronavirus' fault that the economy is bad and is getting worse.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by MagnumOpus on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @10:01AM (#24132143)
The fact that the economy shrank is due to covid response.

The fact that the economy shrank 22% over the last year rather than 12% in Germany or 10% in the US (a 10% growth difference is _enormous_!) is up to Brexit and government ministers selected not on the back of competence but by picking from the strongest Brexit advocates.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by peterclary on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:50AM (#24132060)
Things had already started looking very shaky even before Covid-19. City firms moving jobs abroad. Companies seeing orders drop off as EU buyers switched to sources that wouldn’t be affected if the UK left the transition period without a deal. Even with a deal, not being in the same customs union introduces issues that EU customers can avoid by switching suppliers.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by maxehmookau on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:56AM (#24130635)
Yes, but Brexit won't help the (now much more acutely needed) recovery.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by lol768 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:08AM (#24130724)
> I have just left the UK, several Europeans I know, working in tech, are doing the same. Not data backed, just personal experience. Maybe this is going to be even tougher than expected. Hopefully not.

Out of interest, where did you end up?

Ireland looks tempting to me, given I currently work as a contractor (and the tax law isn't too hostile) and it's not _too_ far away.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by barrenko on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:54AM (#24130610)
I dunno, the point of hard moves like Brexit is that it gets way worse before it gets better. But I'm sure it will be better.

Germany and the rest of EU are just oblivious for now.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by imtringued on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:22AM (#24131288)
What will get better? There are basically no economic benefits since the UK still has to follow EU regulations and pay tariffs on top of that, if it wants to export its products and services to EU countries.

The biggest change is that the UK can close its borders to citizens of EU countries.

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by danjac on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:47AM (#24131489)
Brexit at this point is a faith-based religion based on a mythical "British exceptionalism" that views any attempt at compromise as heresy. No serious expert in economics or international trade thinks it's a good idea.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by danjac on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:55AM (#24130621)
> But I'm sure it will be better.

Based on what exactly?

Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by raxxorrax on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:03AM (#24130688)
Economic predictions are never based on anything aside from the most obvious events. We will see is probably the most realistic estimate.
Re:UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years by LatteLazy on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:48AM (#24130565)
Congrats on getting out!