Also, there is that credential thing and the higher paycheck. And the networking.
As an ex-academic with this view, how much stock do you put in credentials?
Medicine is a good example. As a patient you don't really have the expertise (and maybe not the time) to determine if your physician is of good quality. You rely, partially, on the credential received by getting a medical degree and passing the boards. While not perfect, it gives you some information.
The same goes for computer science. If I were looking for an expert witness for some computer science related legal case I'd take their credentials into account -- in part because a jury will.
But hiring a programmer is different. Like I said in my original post a computer science degree isn't a programming credential. There's some overlap, but the degree of overlap is variable and generally unrelated to program quality -- Stanford tends to have a lot more pragmatic "programming" courses than MIT, at least historically.
Additionally with hiring a programmer you, the person doing the hiring is also usually an expert in the field. You can more easily ascertain their degree of knowledge and aptitude in areas you care about. Plus you have more time to do so (you'll usually get a full day if not more to question them).
Now with that said, do I consider CS degrees when hiring? Honestly it depends. If I was hiring someone to do some signal processing work I'm more inclined to look for someone with graduate degree background in the field, as a starting point. It's a domain that tracks closely to foundational work. OTOH, for a web dev I'm just as likely to hire someone who dropped out of high school as a PhD -- since frankly the PhD probably has spent less time doing web development than anyone else. But in all cases, if you come to me with some asset that shows great skill in what I'm looking for -- maybe a portfolio, or a paper you wrote, or a program, or a recommendation from someone I respect -- that will always get you in the door, period.
read "After credentials" ~ http://paulgraham.com/credentials.html
This is one of the core tenants of the right, which is to maintain the status quo with respect to power. The easiest way to do this is to end entitlements, get rid of taxes, most importantly the estate tax.
And while in college were probably self-taught too. As an ex-academic I believe formal education is about credentialing. Being able to tell someone that you've acquired a degree of mastery we believe is appropriate to some level. And that's fine, but I fundamentally believe that all learning is really self-taught.
Someone lecturing to you is just a different medium from reading it in a book or online video. In all these cases someone who knows the topic better than yourself has manifest some information in some way for you to learn. (It's not like anyone using the term "self-taught" actually means they learned how to do AI from first principles. They learned it by reading a book written by Russell & Norvig.)
And with that said, let me say that CS isn't programming. No more than a degree in biology is the same as being a doctor. In fact the profession of doctor is so specialized they created a special degree just for it, with residencies in specialties -- and you don't need a bio undergrad degree to get into med school.
And as a general rule, if you're passionate about an intellectual pursuit you'll probably be pretty good in it (not asserting how the causality works). Those that learn via books outside of a formal setting are self-selected as it requires a special type of discipline. Although as more people race to become founders and teach themselves, this pool probably gets diluted.