News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by freshfunk on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @02:12PM (#2412036)
To be fair, you should actually quote what I wrote which was:

"Personally, I think the differences come at the top end. I think computer science students who've spent a lot of time doing research (particularly Ph.D.s) gain something that can't be self-taught."

So, in this context, I think it makes sense. Yes, there will always be edge cases like Ramanujan (0.00001% of the population) but I took a little liberty not to qualify every single statement I made.

If anything, this was more about giving respect to the <1% of people who have Ph.D's. But I guess you were offended.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by oniTony on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @02:20PM (#2412071)
But wouldn't a Ph.D., as in reading research papers and arriving at some unique new insight, be closer to "self-taught" than "taught existing knowledge from someone's lecture"?
Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by joshuaeckroth on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @02:28PM (#2412103)
As a PhD student myself, I've realized that working through the program is only half "reading research papers and arriving at some unique insight," which you could say is self-teaching. The other half is presenting your ideas to your advisor, peers, faculty, etc. and handling significant criticism. This occurs in higher-level classes, as well, in which the feedback from the prof. is a very important part of the experience. That, of course, is not "self-teaching," far from it.

On a more general note, I think people should not make claims about what happens in situations (e.g. PhD programs) that one has not experienced herself. Claims like "whatever that person learned in college could have been learned outside college" is too often false simply because no one person can experience both sides of the debate.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by agentultra on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @05:23PM (#2412803)
To be fair, the life of a PhD student is pretty well documented.

I don't think the first hand experience has much value except to the individual experiencing it.

As to the value of a PhD; it's a social construct afaik. It's value is in the reputation you build which is vetted by other PhDs and organizations, your dissertations and debates, by the body of work you publish, and so on. Take all of that away and you're left with just the knowledge which is pretty much available to anyone with half a brain and a spark of curiosity.

It's ludicrous to think that I should invest years of my life and more money than most people make in a year in order to learn how to develop an operating system. That knowledge is freely available and easily accessible. Computer vision? Check. Machine learning? Check. Statistics? Check. You don't go to university for a CS degree in order to learn how to program operating systems or figure out data structures. That would be an incredible waste of time and money.

Someone who is self-taught is simply self-taught. They may have decided that they don't need the rigors of a formal education. Perhaps they don't care about publishing papers and defending them against critics. However, there's no way to say quantatively that a self-taught programmer is better or worse than a formally educated one. It's purely a value statement and one I find is loaded with a lot of FUD.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by freshfunk on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @06:03PM (#2412946)
I don't know. I found two Ph.D. students who's work ended up being pretty important for them... and the rest of the world:

http://infolab.stanford.edu/~sergey/ http://infolab.stanford.edu/~page/

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by agentultra on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @09:46PM (#2413576)
Well what do you know? We can start from there.

If you think I am implying the PhD's do not produce important work, I think you are mistaken.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by MrVitaliy on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @11:48PM (#2413829)
I think this is similar to why Silicon Valley is so attractive as a start-up hub. You have seasoned VC's (instructors) and bright peers as your self (other students).

You can do it all by your self, it's just going to more time to find funding and partners. Something your competitors in SV would have an upper hand with.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by thezilch on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @08:48PM (#2413447)
The second half of your experience can be had on github, launchpad, bitbucket, or project pages http://www.chromium.org/ or http://source.android.com/, where one can find advisors, peers, and faculty to rip your work a new one. As well, this translates nicely to the experience one might expect from a future workplace. Many of these projects have everything one would need to self-teach process, humility, and success:

* http://source.android.com/source/submit-patches.html

* http://source.android.com/source/life-of-a-patch.html

* http://source.android.com/source/code-style.html

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by kd0amg on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @02:24PM (#2412084)
If you insist on classifying into those two categories, sure, but when you bring up grad school, there's a lot more to formal education than sitting in lectures.
Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by entangld on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @04:31PM (#2412586)
It wasn't fair, but I wasn't intentionally taking you out of context. I was kinda heated and paraphrasing from memory (not an accurate way of quoting).

It's not specifically against you, but against an attitude many other people have. The people that believe that knowledge must be handed down to you by authorities. Sometimes those authorities are handing you someone else's logic and experience even though I could understand it on my own. I don't believe every idea/concept needs an interpreter.

Apologies for the misquote.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by freshfunk on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @07:07PM (#2413174)
Appreciate it and I understand.

On the whole, I thought my post was pretty balanced. At the end I talk about how I'm looking for people to work with (cofounders / core team) and I care more about their ability to hack than which school they came from.

I also said that people with degrees from good schools can become complacent and lazy because they always fall back on it whereas someone without a degree could be a better producer of good work.

Re:Self-Taught Programmers vs CS-Educated Programmers by freshfunk on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @02:23PM (#2412082)
@oniTony: For sure. I was thinking more along the lines of the time, effort and resources used in the pursuit of a Ph.D that make it unattainable for most people.