News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than 100 coal-fired plants have been converted to na... by Retric on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @06:39AM (#24118968)
I chose 100 years since you seemed to imply that since methane was "front loaded" then "...there are significant benefits from eventually moving to something else, but little long term advantage due to methane from doing so sooner.

Ahh, ok I genuinely assumed you understood what that number meant and chose to use it incorrectly.

As to 86 for 20 years still being important. These methane leaks from natural gas are nowhere near 1/86th of global CO2 production. They are not even 1/86th of the displaced CO2 from reduced coal use age.

Compare ~10 megatonnes of methane leaks worldwide from all sources of natural gas with global Fossil CO2 emissions at ~37,000 megatons per year and 740,000 over 20. Except your natural gas emissions don’t stack linearly for 20 years with past emissions. So natural gas power plants are easily a net reduction in global warming over your 20 year timetable.

Re:More than 100 coal-fired plants have been converted to na... by opo on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:05PM (#24122704)
>...Compare ~10 megatonnes of methane leaks worldwide

It isn't clear we fully understand the extent of methane leaks in the US and probably have less info on many other countries.

This is illustrated in the Aliso Canyon leak:

>..The authors believe there are important lessons to be learned from the leak - particularly the need to monitor oil and gas facilities more carefully. They say that there has been little co-ordinated oversight of the biggest oil and gas leaks in recent years. They point to Aliso Canyon, the BP spill and the Total Elgin rig blowout in the North Sea as examples where luck more than intent ensured the impacts on the environment were monitored. In the case of Aliso Canyon, the surveying aircraft was working on another project searching for pipeline problems, when the scientists were asked to overfly the leaking well. "The state's response to Aliso Canyon was teed off by the first measurement we took, at that point no-one had any clue that this was 50,000kg per hour of gas," said Dr Conley.

This report discusses the overall level of uncertainty in this area:

>...However, given limited current evidence, it is likely that leakage at individual natural gas well sites is high enough, when combined with leakage from downstream operations, to make the total leakage exceed the 3.2% threshold beyond which gas becomes worse for the climate than coal for at least some period of time.

https://www.pnas.org/content/109/17/6435

Using coal for fuel is almost a crime against humanity considering the health costs, so switching to natural gas is harm reduction. The amount of reduction in GHG production though is more uncertain due to lack of investments in monitoring and reducing methane leakages.

Re:More than 100 coal-fired plants have been converted to na... by Retric on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:23PM (#24123833)
That’s from 2012, we currently have vastly better satellite monitoring of leaks. This provided dual benefits of better measurement and reduction in the number of active leaks thus reducing emissions.