Re:CEO of Uber: Gig Workers Deserve Better
by AnthonyMouse on Monday August 10, 2020 @05:04PM
(#24113974)
> Unlike a short-term supply and demand curve, the economy operates on long-term shifts of aggregate labor supply and demand, in which an increase of aggregate supply of labor causes an aggregate increase in demand for labor (by modifying the overall demand curve of goods - consumption goes up)
There are two problems here. The first is that not all goods have elastic supply and the second is that it's assuming the conclusion because you can't get an increase in demand if the initial decline in wages exceeds the increase in workforce participation.
In the first case, for example, you go from a one income household to a two income household with no increase in housing supply and housing prices just increase to eat the difference.
In the second case, if the increase in labor availability causes wages to decline from $60,000 to $30,000, there being twice as many people making half as much money doesn't lead to an increase in consumption. In theory it could even be worse than this because there is no requirement that the relationship be linear. Doubling labor availability could cause short-term wages to decline only from $60,000 to $55,000 or from $100,000 to $20,000. It depends on the supply and demand curves at the time.
And all of this is industry specific, so how it affects you depends on the work you're qualified to do.
Another issue in this context is that we're just completely disregarding the value of the household labor that had been occurring in the alternative. If someone goes from being a homemaker to working a $35,000/year job, but then as a result loses $35,000 to taxes, childcare, commuting expenses, restaurants, a housekeeper and so on, from a GDP perspective it gets counted as net increases all around even though it's really just breaking even. Or worse than breaking even after the effects of the two income trap increasing the cost of supply-inelastic products like housing.
There are two problems here. The first is that not all goods have elastic supply and the second is that it's assuming the conclusion because you can't get an increase in demand if the initial decline in wages exceeds the increase in workforce participation.
In the first case, for example, you go from a one income household to a two income household with no increase in housing supply and housing prices just increase to eat the difference.
In the second case, if the increase in labor availability causes wages to decline from $60,000 to $30,000, there being twice as many people making half as much money doesn't lead to an increase in consumption. In theory it could even be worse than this because there is no requirement that the relationship be linear. Doubling labor availability could cause short-term wages to decline only from $60,000 to $55,000 or from $100,000 to $20,000. It depends on the supply and demand curves at the time.
And all of this is industry specific, so how it affects you depends on the work you're qualified to do.
Another issue in this context is that we're just completely disregarding the value of the household labor that had been occurring in the alternative. If someone goes from being a homemaker to working a $35,000/year job, but then as a result loses $35,000 to taxes, childcare, commuting expenses, restaurants, a housekeeper and so on, from a GDP perspective it gets counted as net increases all around even though it's really just breaking even. Or worse than breaking even after the effects of the two income trap increasing the cost of supply-inelastic products like housing.