Re:Ask HN:Review My Updated Side Project - ShelfLuv.com (250...
by JoachimSchipper on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @06:19AM
(#2410377)
Some random comments:
- the front page loads slowly (FF4).
- <title> in <body>?
- I expected the image to change if I moused over the buttons below; I needed to click. I usually hate "active" mouseovers, but it's still something to think about
- the 'log in with Facebook' text crosses the grey/white border, which is jarring
- I wouldn't use this anyway, but there'd be no way I'd sign up for Facebook to use this.
- do the "as seen on" logos do anything for your readers? I only recognized LifeHacker, and I've almost never read anything of theirs.
- the bar at the top is annoying; then again, I always find a bar at the top annoying.
- the per-book pages (e.g. http://www.shelfluv.com/ASIN/1430219483) contain a summary, but it's somewhat hard to find and the text is set in too narrow a column. Maybe place a sentence or two above the comments/recent activity, with a "(more)" button to expand?
- the front page loads slowly (FF4).
- <title> in <body>?
- I expected the image to change if I moused over the buttons below; I needed to click. I usually hate "active" mouseovers, but it's still something to think about
- the 'log in with Facebook' text crosses the grey/white border, which is jarring
- I wouldn't use this anyway, but there'd be no way I'd sign up for Facebook to use this.
- do the "as seen on" logos do anything for your readers? I only recognized LifeHacker, and I've almost never read anything of theirs.
- the bar at the top is annoying; then again, I always find a bar at the top annoying.
- the per-book pages (e.g. http://www.shelfluv.com/ASIN/1430219483) contain a summary, but it's somewhat hard to find and the text is set in too narrow a column. Maybe place a sentence or two above the comments/recent activity, with a "(more)" button to expand?