Re:The Woeful Inadequacy of School Reopening Plans
by yellow_postit on Sunday August 09, 2020 @11:26AM
(#24100184)
A younger ages I don’t see it as a platform problem — humans rely on a plethora of non verbal social and environmental cues which are not replicable when every interaction is disintermediated by a screen.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Woeful Inadequacy of School Reopening Plans
by jonahbenton on Sunday August 09, 2020 @12:19PM
(#24100627)
Speaking as an ed-tech advocate and practitioner, having written games and platforms for kids, worked in schools, have kids who program- I can't align with this perspective enough.
We are biological/physical/chemical/etc embodied entities, with a spectrum of interactions, especially sub-teen- the range of which far exceeds present understanding.
Children need literal human contact, on real-life modalities, to survive and thrive. A child raised by screens would die.
For the later high school set, potential improvements within the limited screen modalities have some value, but still- this all reminds of early AI framings, where a machine playing chess was thought to be the sum total of human engagement capability. Those making the argument didn't even know how not-even-wrong they are.