Re:Infinity: open-source search engine
by hinkley on Friday August 07, 2020 @07:05PM
(#24087321)
TANSTAAFL shouldn't have to be said either, and yet here we are.
This would be an interesting ethical discussion if it weren't predicated on a conversation every parent has with their 14 year old.
Yes, I know you want this thing, but things don't just magically appear. It all takes effort. Are you going to contribute? Or do you just expect other people to do stuff for you or you'll throw a tantrum? You are getting older now and this is not acceptable behavior.
The problem is not ads. The problem is that people want things for free. If you get things for free you're not a customer. If you're neither the customer or the vendor in the transaction, then you are the product. Ads are by far the most obvious form of this but there are others actors who would be much, much worse if they were the customer. If 'somebody worse than ads' are the only customers, then they will just get more brazen. Like loan shark brazen, or possibly police state brazen.
We need a way to pay for things that's not a paywall, and not a surveillance state. Given the other conversations in this thread, this company is trying to be neither. Whether they succeed or have ulterior motives I have no way of knowing.
If you have the name recognition of Wikipedia or PBS, you can to a fund raising campaign every year. You can seek funding from a foundation of some sort. If you're just a few people with an MVP? Neither of those will work for you. (I suppose maybe GoFundMe might, but I wouldn't count on it.)
This would be an interesting ethical discussion if it weren't predicated on a conversation every parent has with their 14 year old.
Yes, I know you want this thing, but things don't just magically appear. It all takes effort. Are you going to contribute? Or do you just expect other people to do stuff for you or you'll throw a tantrum? You are getting older now and this is not acceptable behavior.
The problem is not ads. The problem is that people want things for free. If you get things for free you're not a customer. If you're neither the customer or the vendor in the transaction, then you are the product. Ads are by far the most obvious form of this but there are others actors who would be much, much worse if they were the customer. If 'somebody worse than ads' are the only customers, then they will just get more brazen. Like loan shark brazen, or possibly police state brazen.
We need a way to pay for things that's not a paywall, and not a surveillance state. Given the other conversations in this thread, this company is trying to be neither. Whether they succeed or have ulterior motives I have no way of knowing.
If you have the name recognition of Wikipedia or PBS, you can to a fund raising campaign every year. You can seek funding from a foundation of some sort. If you're just a few people with an MVP? Neither of those will work for you. (I suppose maybe GoFundMe might, but I wouldn't count on it.)