States shouldn't be trying to clip overall service expenditures during a massive economic and public health emergency that creates novel challenges for education delivery (health, economic safety net, and education cover much of the big ticket state spending items, and this situation creates additional demands on all of them.)
And, unlike the feds, states can't as a practical (and usually constitutional) matter meet temporary emergency need with deficit spending for operations, because most have Constitutional balanced operating budget requirements but, more importantly (because it's a constraint that applies whatever the state chooses), they have a much higher cost of borrowing because they aren’t currency issuers whose debt is in their own currency.
For that reason, it's normal for the federal government to backstop the states on major emergencies specifically so they aren't forced to make temporary economic emergencies worse by taking more money out through spending cuts or saddle taxpayers with greater debts than if the feds were paying by borrowing at the state level.
Like, even if they care not a whit about the people involved (they don't), it is republicans' own self interest that they do not go into the 2020 elections having crashed the economy at an absolutely unprecedented rate. They should be doing whatever it takes to avert it.
Numbers like "33% annualized decline in the economy" should be striking fear into everyone's heart. We are speedrunning the great depression, the great depression took five years to hit bottom, we are going to do it in a year or so unless something drastic is done.
That's the problem here. The states are using the emergency to bail out their pension and other over spending that was a problem even without the pandemic. For years now, they've been warned that the promises they made could not be kept. The math doesn't lie.
They didn't care. They figured they'd worry about it when the time came, always passing the buck to the next politicians. Well, the pandemic and lack of tax revenue has now brought that point forward.
The rest of us - especially those of us in red states who've been listening to raging blue states scream at us for being 'subsidized by them' for the last decade - are paying attention to this backhanded bailout for fiscal problems not directly related to covid.
This is obviously flawed, and the initial idea was income replacement so your income remained the same, but the state of the IT infrastructure in unemployment offices across the US is so dismal there was no way they could cope with that requirement.
And how many Americans has that pandemic killed over the last few months?
The real pandemic is people dying and being disabled, not debt. Saying it's debt is callous and cruel as people are dying and becoming disabled all around us. How is it possible to have no empathy at all like this?
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_impact_of_the_COVID-1...
Hyperbolic.
This is so frustrating to me. States pretend like their budgets are sacrosanct and refuse to take any action to prepare themselves. They’ll milk every last drop from their constituents before they start cutting fat.
Very many states going into this had substantial rainy day funds, and many states have done what they can't to cut expense:service ratios while boosting services (sometimes under preprogrammed, federally-governed formulas, as for many state-federal confunded entitlements) such as employee pay cuts (like the furloughs in California). The idea that states have done nothing to prepare or that states aren't taking steps on their own is preposterous. States are structurally more limited than the feds in how they can financially respond to an urgent crises, and for that reason have always relied on the feds being part of that response, but they are not generally failing to do their part as far as financial steps; some are falling down on the public health parts, but mostly that's a result of pressure directed from the federal executive branch, not independent state intransigence or nonfeasance.
Also any service that is temporarily furloughed because of shelter-at-home should have their employees furloughed as well. In other words they should experience the pain the same way as the rest of us.
* https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2018/10/26/ill...
Worse is the stuffing of the bills with defense appropriations and more items not related to COVID19. Worse is the attempt to feed the state governments between five hundred to a trillion dollars to shore up budgets of states that are not even trying to clip their expenditures, most of this is routed towards shoring up their pension systems and again, not COVID19 related.
The real pandemic is the debt bomb that Congress is foisting on the American public, remember, no serious crisis can be allowed to go to waste. It is time for the money to flow to friends and family.