Re:CNO neutrinos from the Sun are finally detected
by steffenfrost on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:16AM
(#24082069)
Why is the metallicity of the sun so low when they are so high for the planets?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:CNO neutrinos from the Sun are finally detected
by kadoban on Friday August 07, 2020 @11:16AM
(#24082761)
I think because H2 is so common. Given that and how gravity works, let's look at the possibilities:
small thing (say up to size of smaller planets): only solids can clump together and stay together, gas would just fizz away
medium thing (earthish to gas giantish, say): solids clump together and that provides enough gravity (and sometimes magnetics) to capture/keep some gas too
large thing (star sized): you can just capture everything around. Sure that'll contain some metal, but since most of what's out there is H2 and you're gulping it all up, you end up mostly gas
Re:CNO neutrinos from the Sun are finally detected
by ncmncm on Friday August 07, 2020 @10:46AM
(#24082418)
Which planets? The big ones are mostly H2. The small fry with weak gravity lose theirs.
Re:CNO neutrinos from the Sun are finally detected
by steffenfrost on Saturday August 08, 2020 @09:09AM
(#24091367)
There is new data from the Juno Mission, that Jupiter has a diluted core.
"...heavy elements (elements other than hydrogen and helium) are distributed within a region extending to nearly half of Jupiter’s radius."