I feel as though, like Digg, this is going to be an astonishingly effective mechanism for getting Kevin Rose attention.
I think you are taking away from Kevin. He actually changed the way we consume news online. It is arguable that he invented the very social-news-voting system we are using on HN. I can guarantee you a very small percentage of people who use sites that follow the Digg model know who KR is.
Edit: And I do not mean to be rude, but how does your contribution to the internet compare to his?
> It is arguable that he invented the very social-news-voting system we are using on HN.
Given that Reddit was a Y Combinator company, my strong suspicion is that HN took its inspiration from sources other than Digg.
> Edit: And I do not mean to be rude, but how does your contribution to the internet compare to his?
My contribution is immaterial to the discussion. Pointing out that Kevin Rose does much better work as an internet celebrity than as a business leader would remain true (or false) whether I'm Danilo Campos or Vinton Cerf.
Let's ask PG to disable commenting on stories. :)
And probably not much more than that.
What mystifies me is why he doesn't just focus on the thing he's good at: being in the spotlight. I think Digg made pretty clear the fact that he's just not the guy you want doing the day to day, tedious, mostly obscure work of running a company.
Which is fine.
Maybe he could go to acting school. Or do a vlog?