I see. I guess it ends up doing something a bit unexpected because the distribution it's sampling from is quite different from the numbers people often deal with (also unlike the example on the main page it can apparently fail to find a function that is more accurate for all inputs).

Also this is a bit of a special case because it's easy to show that x - x^2 / 2 is within 10^-15 of the true value provided abs(x) is within 10^-6 or so, so it's easy to figure out how good Herbie is doing.