5.5. Derive a hypothesis for why the 50 other competitors have not already solved this problem or couldn't do so quickly once they discover your solution.
If you don't have a good answer for this, then the odds are one of two things will happen:
1. You will waste a bunch of time only to discover that you were ignorant of some deep constraint of the problem area.
2. Your competition will re-implement your feature and crowd you out.
I think the ideal answer would be "if they tried to solve this problem it would be bad for them. Too distracting, and they'd half ass it because it isn't their focus".
Rather than "oh that little feature is on the backlog".
Most markets with existing companies serving them are big enough to support a small indie company. And there are things you can offer as a small company that's difficult for big company's to offer.
So I think your expectation, assuming you are in the US, is that your business has one of a few trajectories:
* You deliberately aim for a market with many small businesses and forces that go against consolidation. There are fewer of these over time, but anything explicitly local, has few economies of scale, or where consumers specifically target variety is a good place to look. Think restaurants, luthiers, and other "craft" businesses. Then you can have a long moderate term success while staying small. You probably won't get rich but you might like your life.
* You try to grow very rapidly to get to be a big fish before the other big fish eat you. You take a ride on the VC train and if you're lucky escape with your soul intact.
* You aim to get bought. You lose the experience of it being your business but you might get rich in return.
* You get crushed or bought against your will. Short of simply fading away from lack of success, this is probably the most likely outcome.
Oh, and allow me to filter out reviews with over x emojis and over 0 animated gifs.
I’d say those are my main complaints/missing features for goodreads ;)
I think 6 only works if you can manually complete the process behind the product to give the buyer the illusion that the product is a real product.
1. Start with markets with high competition. E.g. paid alternatives to Google forms.
2. Get a list of 50+ products competing in the space. If < 50 go back to step 1.
3. Google to find what people, who are on the paid tiers of those products, complain about. This is easy as I am now Googling brand names so should get laser targeted results (v.s. googling "problem I had creating a form" -> Stack Overflow user who'll never pay for a form!)
4. Interview them to dig in further. If you can't get any of these people to even spare 5 minutes to talk, then it might be an indicator that you wont get them to buy.
5. Based on this, derive a hypothesis for a MVP that would solve the problem, along with the market it serves and where to find these people.
6. Presell to people in #4. If they say no - dig in further as to why. If they say yes, aim for maybe $1000 monthly revenue presold, then build.
The reason for this approach is it filters for the "are people motivated enough to spend money" which I think is the biggest risk for the ideas I come up with. Since they are (they already use the "competitor" product"), can I carve out a niche where I do something better for a specific group of people? Can I reach them easily without spending crazy money on ads? And am I solving their problem?
Caveat is this is designed as an idea generator for an Indie Hacker style project, not a startup!