Re:Ebook Fraud
by dotBen on Monday April 04, 2011 @05:21PM
(#2408586)
I've always felt it strange how Amazon has concentrated its resource on penalizing their own customers by locking down the portability/sharability of books - thus preventing customers from their full rights under copyright (such as full right to loan or sell on a book). They'll even enforce that by removing the API keys to sites like Lendle.
Yet they totally leave the door open for scammers to upload content they don't own the copyright to and have no interest in really enforcing that side of the business.
It's the main reason I won't buy a Kindle, as much as the thought of owning a beautiful ebook device reader attracts me so much.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by mcpherrinm on Tuesday April 05, 2011 @04:02AM
(#2410117)
With Kindle, you can lend books out. I don't any internal details on Lendle, but the action doesn't actually stop lending services, from what I can see.
It's really a fine balancing act of trying to deliver the best customer experience (Which Amazon really does want to do). Without the co-operation of publishers, there wouldn't be any content, and then what's the point? Before Amazon pushed the publishers, the eBook market was tiny and unfriendly. Getting the experience as good as it is today has been a colossal amount of effort.
I don't know how enforcement is on scammy books, but I can't seem them being a positive user experience, so I can only assume that some action should be taken.
But at the same time, you really don't want to take down stuff unless you're sure you want to. It is non-trivial to determine who owns what content, and requires human intervention.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by hugh3 on Monday April 04, 2011 @07:21PM
(#2409010)
It's the main reason I won't buy a Kindle, as much as the thought of owning a beautiful ebook device reader attracts me so much.
So buy a Nook. Or a Sony.
I have a Nook which I use exclusively for out-of-copyright content. (I doubt I'd ever pay real money for an eBook, since I like paper books far too much.)
Re:Ebook Fraud
by elai on Monday April 04, 2011 @08:09PM
(#2409134)
Sony pocket reader would be near perfect if they added amazon's side buttons, and a one/two tap method to get to a fully expanded out table of contents like iBooks. Being able to use it while charging from the computer would be nice too.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by Estragon on Monday April 04, 2011 @07:25PM
(#2409023)
It's not strange at all. Obviously Amazon makes money every time you buy Kindle content, even if it's crap, whereas Lendle threatened to reduce their revenue.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by alanfalcon on Monday April 04, 2011 @01:47PM
(#2407646)
Reminds me of the Drudge Report "app" that was simply a mobile version of the site created by Jon Gales, without permission from Jon Gales (or, presumably, Matt Drudge).
Re:Ebook Fraud
by jonknee on Monday April 04, 2011 @07:52PM
(#2409088)
For anyone who missed it, that case ended well enough. I muscled them into giving a $10,000 donation to the Red Cross and after making it they transitioned off my servers. Best of both worlds as I never felt right about making money off it as I was screen scraping Drudge's curated links in the first place.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by nikcub on Monday April 04, 2011 @09:26PM
(#2409306)
I found Techcrunch on there a half dozen times, all paid subscriptions. Was only alerted to it when somebody asked 'hey why don't you make your Kindle edition free or cheaper than $5 a month' and I said 'we don't have a kindle edition'.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by ck2 on Monday April 04, 2011 @03:13PM
(#2408055)
(all the following was a mistake I misread the comments somehow as part of his own post)
He's said some pretty brave things for someone who says he can't afford an attorney. Maybe he shouldn't be admitting that?
Is it legal for Amazon to ignore DMCA requests of any kind? "Safe Harbor" laws do not allow them to set restrictions like "only on law firm letterhead" do they? Some lawfirm should set up a $50 DMCA online form that faxes to Amazon.
Re:Ebook Fraud
by Groxx on Monday April 04, 2011 @03:59PM
(#2408248)
I don't follow. Nothing in there is even remotely grounds for legal action - it can all be verified by pointing to a single example, and even at worst it's opinion and using the most well-known site as an example. And there's no mention of "DMCA" anywhere by Bruce, just by commenters.
Did the content change between your post and my reading? Or are you connecting commenters (ie, Carl Bussjaeger) with Bruce?
Yet they totally leave the door open for scammers to upload content they don't own the copyright to and have no interest in really enforcing that side of the business.
It's the main reason I won't buy a Kindle, as much as the thought of owning a beautiful ebook device reader attracts me so much.
It's really a fine balancing act of trying to deliver the best customer experience (Which Amazon really does want to do). Without the co-operation of publishers, there wouldn't be any content, and then what's the point? Before Amazon pushed the publishers, the eBook market was tiny and unfriendly. Getting the experience as good as it is today has been a colossal amount of effort.
I don't know how enforcement is on scammy books, but I can't seem them being a positive user experience, so I can only assume that some action should be taken.
But at the same time, you really don't want to take down stuff unless you're sure you want to. It is non-trivial to determine who owns what content, and requires human intervention.
So buy a Nook. Or a Sony.
I have a Nook which I use exclusively for out-of-copyright content. (I doubt I'd ever pay real money for an eBook, since I like paper books far too much.)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2329283
http://www.jongales.com/blog/2011/03/18/hacker-news-comment-...
Pure gold.
He's said some pretty brave things for someone who says he can't afford an attorney. Maybe he shouldn't be admitting that?
Is it legal for Amazon to ignore DMCA requests of any kind? "Safe Harbor" laws do not allow them to set restrictions like "only on law firm letterhead" do they? Some lawfirm should set up a $50 DMCA online form that faxes to Amazon.
Did the content change between your post and my reading? Or are you connecting commenters (ie, Carl Bussjaeger) with Bruce?
Sheesh, can I blame it on poor sleep last night?
That was embarrassing! (but he needs to format comments differently than his posts)