That sounds way better, and quite possibly more effective at actually catching shoplifting. My experience in the UK, Ireland US and Canada has been the bad example as you have described.
It seems to be a classic case of bureaucratic risk aversion without proper cost analysis.
Some items like fresh fruits & vegetables are usually loose & sold by weight. How are things like this handled without scales?
This is a huge contrast with my experience in the UK. Those scanners are talking, are slow to move between states, require you to put everything from one to another scale. This is indeed often slower than a human worker, and amazes me to no end.