News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You don’t need reproducible builds by joshuamorton on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @12:53PM (#24062927)
> Surely the vast majority of testing happens on non-release builds, despite the fact that release builds may also be tested.

Of course.

> I would say that hardly anyone runs unit tests on release build artifacts just because it takes forever to produce them.

I don't know that this follows: just because 99% of the invocations of your unit test are in fastbuild doesn't mean that you don't also test everything in opt at least once.

Re:You don’t need reproducible builds by jeffbee on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @01:01PM (#24063022)
I can't remember seeing any cc_test target at Google that ran with realistic release optimizations (AutoFDO/SamplePGO+LTO) and even if they did it's still not the release binary because it links in the test case and the test main function.
Re:You don’t need reproducible builds by joshuamorton on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @01:12PM (#24063128)
Did you look in the CI system for configurations there? I see FDO enabled in those tests. (Speaking at a high level, configurations can be modified in bazelrc and with flags without being explicitly listed in the cc_test rule itself)

> release binary because it links in the test case and the test main function.

Sure, but it's verifiably the same object files as get put into the release artifact.

Re:You don’t need reproducible builds by tomjakubowski on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @03:03PM (#24064307)
> Sure, but it's verifiably the same object files as get put into the release artifact.

Well, not if you use LTO.