Also curious, is it possible that the 15 mins of sunlight per day was the actual cure, rather than the supplements?
There are days where I bask in sunlight and others where I'm mostly in my hidey hole (esp. with the pandemic), so nothing too consistent. My post wasn't too clear about that, but yeah, I had stopped the dermatologist treatments (other than T-Gel shampoo) prior to the Vitamin D thing.
How is it even plausible that sunlight does not have significant health benefits, given that Europeans evolved to have pale skin because they lived in high latitude environments?
No one is arguing that sunlight doesn’t have benefits. We just don’t know if those benefits are mediated through vitamin D (in which case supplementation could be enough!) or something else.
(Perhaps not coincidentally, placebo effects in depression are known to be large).
You rightfully mention a high correlation with other metrics that make, in my opinion, vitamin d health benefits and health disadvantages scientifically impenetrable.
As a tiny datapoint, I refer to the research of the (on hn at least) highly acclaimed Dr. Rhonda Patrick, who states that 70% of Americans are currently deficient on vitD. She also states that vitD has effects on 5% of gene expression, and is very important in the brain formation of foetuses since it assists the production of serotonin.
If anything, and despite of admittedly huge efforts already, vitD is heavily underresearched and many of its mechanisms unexplored.
I seriously doubt that because I think exactly what it does is poorly understood. But we do know that people with cystic fibrosis have serious compromised immune function and, among other things, see terrible, deadly lung infections (and account for a large percentage of lung transplants).
Some of the remarks in this discussion have been helpful to me and I've spent nearly two decades -- ever since my diagnosis in May 2001 -- trying to understand my condition.
New information comes out all the time and new tidbits that are reasonably verifiable as true become building blocks for more complex mental models. I am just beginning to understand things I've been squirreling information away about for a lot of years with a keen interest because my life literally depended upon such understanding.
I have kind of "bookmarked" this discussion, in part to get me ready access to the article it covers. I'm short of sleep today and not following things well and this piece is piquing my curiosity in ways that most discussions of vitamin D fail to do.
I think this is an exciting era in which to be alive if you have a mystery illness that they don't really know how to fix. The amount of information available at your fingertips while literally laying in bed, too sick to get up, overwhelms what I could find at a library as a child. It is game changing in ways that most people seem to fail to appreciate.
I believe there's a plausible mechanism in this case, and related studies on respiratory infections where an effect was found. Also, in terms of studies, often the no effect data is from bolus doses, which don't seem to do a good job moving the needle.
This randomized controlled trial, with 11000 participants "confirms vitamin D protects against colds and flu":
https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2017/02/study-confirm...
(basically saying they correlate, without leaping onto the cause bandwagon)
In this case, 2,000UI is not a significant amount.
Someone in the UK can generate 10,000UI - 20,000UI from spending 5 mins in the midday summer sun.
This amount various depending on whether they are in the countryside, where about 25% of UVB radiation is absorbed by plants or sunbathing on a concrete/sand surface can reflect 100% of the UVB upwards. If sunbathing in a polluted area, the low level ozone can also reduce the UVB radiation reaching the ground depending on the pollution levels.
The Vit D Receptor has a zinc finger which is seems to only be structural, so it would seem that without enough zinc in the diet, even the 2776 VDR's in the human body according to the Wellcome Trust, Cambridge Aug 2010, most of which are concentrated around the immune system genes wont function optimally.
A point worth noting about Vit D3 supplements derived from Lanolin, aka Sheep Fat/Oil, as most sheep are dipped in organophosphates (Nerve Agents), there is a chance that you could be exposing yourself to harmful residual levels of organophosphates. I've yet to see any legislation which monitors this in Vit D supplements in any region of the world (if you know of any please reply so I can update), so megadosing Vit D3 supplements could be increasing the tiny residual amounts of organophosphates to significant and possibly harmful levels. In a study on different Vit D3 specific supplements, the amounts quoted also varied significantly.
Its also worth noting that due to the way patents work, manufacturers of Vit D serum levels measuring equipment use different methods and markers to calculate your serum 25(O)HD levels, 10 years on, the medical equipment is still not standardised as noted here. https://ods.od.nih.gov/Research/vdsp.aspx In my own limited tests using NHS equipment, the amounts measured varied by 45%.
Like all fat soluble vitamins, D3 (25(O)HD) also has a half life of about 28days so you could do what I have done in the past and purchase some UVB reptile flo tubes and bask under them during the winter months for a few hours a day to monitor serum levels. https://www.reptilecentre.com/blog/2016/09/difference-t8-t5-... If you want to know how UVB levels vary around the world, this is a good resource http://www.uvguide.co.uk/ reptiles like some other mammals also need UVB radiation for good health.
I could go on, I dont agree with some professors in this field, sometimes science seems to be a scientific Ash conformity experiment which can prevent you from becoming a qualified expert and harm your health but as always with health, there is no panacea and a variety of factors influence our health. For example if your kidneys and/or liver are not healthy you wont be able to make as much Vit D. Diet also plays a part, but if you should find yourself getting into hypercalcaemia territory, increase your Vit K intake, eg eat Brussel Sprouts, and increase your Leucine and Lysine intake as these keto amino acids also stimulate all type collagen synthesis and can reduce the calcium in the blood stream.
As the airways are the main entry point, it would seem logical to increase Vit A intake because this is required by all epithilial cells as is choline for cell membrane integrity, and choline also helps to reduce the pressure in alveoli to facilitate gas exchange which also increases physical performance but could make it easier to breath when on a ventilator and Choline also helps clean the blood through methylation. Epithelial cells secrete things, so those two supplements will enable the lungs and airway secretions to work properly producing enough functional mucous in order to trap pathogens before it even gets into the lungs where the real damage can take place. Like I said it would seem logical to do this, but I'm not an expert, just a self taught IT geek like many of you guys. :-)
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/influenza-huma...
There was just a large trial published in JAMA [1] examining its effectiveness for depression given solid observational data. It was not at all effective.
The reason that Vitamin D is associated with many diseases but is not causative for anything is that Vitamin D level is highly correlated with other metrics of health such as socioeconomic status, active lifestyle, nutritional sufficiency, etc.
We are wasting our time and money looking at Vitamin D again and again and again.
1. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/27689...