Re:More than 1/3 of all access to Google is now over IPv6
by throw0101a on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @09:05AM
(#24060341)
> I think it's good that cloud providers push for gateways etc. in order to restrict access on network level.
If the default security group for IPv6 only allows SSH and ICMPv6 to an instance/host, what difference does it make?
* https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AWSEC2/latest/UserGuide/ec2-secu...
It's not the NATing that gives (internal) networks security, it's the stateful packet inspection at the gateway and--more and more--at the host level.
Re:More than 1/3 of all access to Google is now over IPv6
by jiggawatts on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @09:25AM
(#24060489)
Nobody said there wouldn't be ACLs or firewalls in an IPv6 network.
IPv4 NAT provides security as a side effect.
You don't need NAT for security.
PS: This is the #1 most common argument trotted out against IPv6, and it is blatantly false.
Re:More than 1/3 of all access to Google is now over IPv6
by dijit on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @09:49AM
(#24060687)
NAT doesn't do much if anything for security at all, as soon as there's an outbound connection the internet has a port mapping back to your host.
https://www.f5.com/services/resources/white-papers/the-myth-....
Re:More than 1/3 of all access to Google is now over IPv6
by Dagger2 on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @11:42AM
(#24062066)
You don't even need an outbound connection. If your router receives a packet with a dest IP set to one of your LAN machines, it'll be routed to that LAN machine. NAT does nothing to stop that, and thus does nothing for (this aspect of) security.
Re:More than 1/3 of all access to Google is now over IPv6
by Dagger2 on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @10:17AM
(#24061006)
As a side benefit of v6, it makes it harder to find unprotected machines due to the vastly increased address space.
Obviously that doesn't make those machines secure, but an insecure machine that hasn't been exploited is better than an insecure machine that has.
(They still could do IPv6 proper - no argument there)