News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Withdrawing from Hacker News by jseliger on Sunday April 03, 2011 @06:19PM (#2404313)
This: "Perhaps you need 10% of your community to be "trusted elders," and they have the right to declare comments to be of negative value," might be true, but I'm not sure it scales. I don't know if I would count as "trusted elder," but I'm very sparing with my downvotes and reserve them for the stupid, mean, and wildly off-topic comments (which are often "meta" threads about whether a topic belongs, etc.).

"Perhaps bands of karma, expressed as a percentage of the population (or something) could be used to grant and deny more access to features. Making someone's position is the ranking visible will help that be more transparent."

I think any attempt to automate this will be susceptible to gaming, groupthink, and so forth, and it makes karma too much like a game.

Re:Withdrawing from Hacker News by RiderOfGiraffes on Sunday April 03, 2011 @06:24PM (#2404332)
That's why I said these are "toss in the air and see what happens" ideas. They aren't expected to work, and finding fault with them is no real challenge.

Mutating them into something that does work is more important, interesting and useful. There's more discussion here:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696

Enjoy!