Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by tstegart on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @04:29PM
(#240315)
You know I was cleaning this weekend and apparently I missed the start of "Put the smack-down on PG" week. Any way I can catch up by Friday? Suggestions PG? I have a tentative work entitled "Why PG is wrong about the color of the HN menubar," but I'm not sure it has the same pizzaz as this other stuff we're seeing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The point of submitting this wasn't to pick on pg -- it's a thoughtful piece, and adds a new voice to the discussion. Interesting conversations have two sides.
Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by tstegart on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @05:04PM
(#240370)
Thats true. It was not a comment about this article, it was a joke about many articles appearing in a short time frame all disagreeing with PG in some way or another. All the responses seem to have come out at once. Conversations are good, although I have a running disagreement on a different thread over the logic of some comments, I have to say they are enjoyable to read.
Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by wheels on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @08:35PM
(#240580)
It could be a wave returning after he published quite a few in a short batch of time recently. Also I've felt that the newer ones aren't as convincing as some of the older essays.
Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by giles_bowkett on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @07:42PM
(#240527)
well, they're overdue. the man's gotten very lazy preaching to the converted.
Actually this one is a delight by comparison. This guy at least means well. The last one was like Fox News.
Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by ph0rque on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @08:12PM
(#240561)
> I have a tentative work entitled "Why PG is wrong about the color of the HN menubar,"...
You get to disagree about the menubar color at 250+ karma.
Re:Why Paul Graham is wrong about New York City
by Xichekolas on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @11:23PM
(#240733)
You know, I missed the other articles because I was out of town (I assume), but I just wanted to let you know that'd I'd like to nominate this comment for Comment-Of-The-Year award. Here everyone else is setting up for a flame war and you just come along and remind everyone that they are being four-year-olds.