News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by tsimionescu on Sunday August 02, 2020 @05:11AM (#24027435)
Thinking about this with an engineering mindset, how can you know that you are offering equal opportunities of you don't measure the outcomes? What can you measure that shows men are as likely to be given a tech job as women, if not the outcomes of men and women working there? For do you know you've made it as easy for a black student to be a great software developer as it is for a white student, if you don't look at great software developers and measure how many are black or white?
Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by kepler1 on Sunday August 02, 2020 @05:29AM (#24027510)
How do you know if the measurements you're taking at the end of the process are valid to interpret, if you don't know the inputs?

I'm not willing to trust the one (or act on it in a way that distorts what could be an otherwise fair/unbiased process) without knowing the other.

My problem with this approach is that people are too willing to stop halfway and claim that the outcome looks biased, without seeing what the inputs were. And cause (or seek to cause) massive change to people's lives based on that.

Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by tsimionescu on Sunday August 02, 2020 @05:52AM (#24027607)
I absolutely agree, you need to try to measure boy side of the equation, not only the outcomes.
Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by tarsinge on Sunday August 02, 2020 @05:38AM (#24027548)
The problem is that the outcome is an aggregation of a lifelong process, not just the recruiting process. Trying to control the outcome is impossible, because for example there may be cultural reasons (parenting, marketing and advertising, etc...) that may result in only a fraction of a gender being interested in a field. But still we can still aim to offer equal opportunities in a bottom up manner to any candidate.
Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by tsimionescu on Sunday August 02, 2020 @06:00AM (#24027627)
Can it be said that boys and girls have equal opportunity access to IT if girls get taught by parents or teachers or culture at large that computers are for boys? I would argue that it isn't.

So I agree with you in that simply forcing companies to hire more women is not a solution to the problem. But that does not mean that there isn't a problem, or that we can consider education, marketing and advertising, and other cultural reasons as unchangeable.

This is in fact exactly what people mean when they talk about systemic or structural inequality - there is no single point where things are going wrong, it is a whole host of different aspects of our society that together shape outcomes in a bad way.

But as we've seen with gay acceptance, change is absolutely possible, even on deeply divisive topics. And sure, it will take a long time to change the whole culture, and some people will feel deeply, sincerely, disturbed by the changes (like religious fundamentalists are feeling about gay marriage), and inequality will linger. But we do have the power to change.

Note: I'm not arguing equal outcomes in tech employment are as important as equal marriage. I'm just giving a relatively recent example of a massive cultural shift. Probably a more spent example would be the initial push for women's access to the workforce at all, but I believe that feels to distant to us.

Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by jpxw on Sunday August 02, 2020 @05:33AM (#24027526)
There is no way of knowing. Certainly looking at outcomes is a bad way of measuring this, because it presupposes equal interests and desire.
Re:Tech Journalism Is Less Diverse Than Tech by tsimionescu on Sunday August 02, 2020 @06:04AM (#24027639)
Sure, measuring only outcomes is not reliable. But measuring only inputs is also unreliable.