News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @10:57AM (#24020897)
If we could have a hard lockdown for 4-8 weeks and still come out the other end in good financial shape, that would be amazing, and really get the virus under control. If a small number of families could make that happen, let's do it.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by sokoloff on Saturday August 01, 2020 @11:25AM (#24021142)
That reads like “If a small number of families could forfeit several lifetimes’ of fortunes accumulated via serving the needs/wants of vast swaths of population, let’s take their money and do it!”

This seems like something that is much more properly paid via broad-based taxation, not by seizing wealth from a small number of families.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @12:30PM (#24021750)
> That reads like “If a small number of families could forfeit several lifetimes’ of fortunes accumulated via serving the needs/wants of vast swaths of population, let’s take their money and do it!”

"via serving the needs/wants of vast swaths of population" is completely false. The article was about inherited wealth. When you inherit wealth, you didn't serve the needs of vast swaths of the population. You were simply born to the right parents.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by rayiner on Saturday August 01, 2020 @12:09PM (#24021522)
We have already spent 15 times that much money on the lockdowns we did have, and didn’t get the virus under control. And it’s not a “small number of families.” The top 10 richest American families could only cover about 3-4 weeks of lockdowns. The first four months of lockdowns cost as much as the total wealth of the entire Forbes 400, and we’re not even done yet.

And of course, you’re comparing wealth accumulated over 50-60 years to a one time bailout. This likely won’t be the last pandemic of our lifetime. What’ll we do next time?

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @12:22PM (#24021661)
The United States hasn't had a lockdown. Small sections of the US did, but mostly people didn't take it as seriously here as they did in a number of other countries. We basically wasted the money because we only took half-hearted measures.

This is a hundred year pandemic. The worst pandemic since the 1918 flu. We save up during the good times just in case we need it during the bad times. So yes, spending wealth accumulated over the past decades is necessary now.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by xyzzyz on Saturday August 01, 2020 @03:23PM (#24023161)
The worst pandemic since the 1918 flu.

It’s not even as bad as previous Asian flu of 1957, so far.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @03:40PM (#24023278)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1957%E2%80%931958_influenza_pa...

"About 70,000 to 116,000 people died in the United States"

"The second wave, in January and February 1958, was more pronounced among elderly people and so was more fatal."

There have been over 150,000 deaths in the US in the first 7 months of the current pandemic. So no, you're incorrect.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by xyzzyz on Saturday August 01, 2020 @07:23PM (#24024804)
US population is now more than twice of what it was in 1957.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @08:04PM (#24025076)
And 150,000 is more than twice 70,000.

Just stop.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by xyzzyz on Saturday August 01, 2020 @08:20PM (#24025159)
But less than twice 116,000. If you were more charitable to my argument, and less antagonistic towards me, you’d get fewer downvoted.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Sunday August 02, 2020 @09:12AM (#24028499)
The numbers 70,000 to 116,000 are for the entire 1957-1958 pandemic, which of course is done. The number of over 150,000 for the current pandemic is only the deaths to date, which are at a rate of about 1500 per day now and rising. So I'm not clear on what your argument is supposed to be? We could split hairs over the numbers to date, but we know that the current pandemic is very far from over. Is there any serious dispute that when it's over, the current pandemic will surpass 1957-58, if it hasn't already? We don't have a vaccine, only a minority of the population has been infected, and it's still spreading.

I was arguing for a hard lockdown to stop the current increase in cases. I'm not sure how it even matters whether the final toll in 1958 was 70K or 116K or somewhere between. We know the current cases have been trending upward for the past month in the US. Without a lockdown, they're likely to continue trending upward.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by xyzzyz on Sunday August 02, 2020 @01:05PM (#24029883)
No, I agree that this one will be worse than the one in 1957, hence the use of “so far” in my original comment. However, I don’t think it will be very significantly, qualitatively worse than the one in 1957, at least from medical perspective. My point is that the current one is only really worse because of the response and perception.

I think it is reasonable to say that if we followed Swedish approach to COVID, we’d have similar outcomes. The epidemics in Sweden is mostly finished, they get few new cases and very few new deaths. If we had similar fatality rate to Sweden, we’d be looking at 200,000 deaths in the US. That’s an enormous, dizzying numbers. However, it wouldn’t be qualitatively different than 1957 Asian flu, and given how nobody has even heard of 1957 Asian flu epidemics, I claim that we wouldn’t have done such an enormous damage to livelihoods of hundreds of millions of Americans.

The cases in the US are going up, because this is how we go through with this whole ordeal. This is what happened in UK, Italy, Sweden, France, New York or New Jersey. They are now done with epidemics. Look at their graphs, despite relaxation of restrictions, case numbers are very low and flat or trending downwards. New York and New Jersey, with their absolutely disastrous policy of deliberately infecting nursing homes by forcing them to take COVID-positive patients, have most definitely resulted in very high death rates there compared to European countries. However, if instead of lockdowns, we pursued a sensible policy of protecting the most vulnerable, we’d be already done by now and could get on with our lives.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Sunday August 02, 2020 @01:46PM (#24030133)
Ok, I see the problem here:

> The epidemics in Sweden is mostly finished

> This is what happened in UK, Italy, Sweden, France, New York or New Jersey. They are now done with epidemics.

This is just way off base.

"Five months into Europe's pandemic and only 6% of the population here is known to have antibodies, according to Swedish Public Health Agency research." https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53498133

The rate is difficult to measure, but even if it's significantly higher than 6%, it's nowhere near the estimated 70% required for herd immunity.

Life has not returned to normal, anywhere. They're still social distancing in New York and New Jersey, and even in Sweden.

Bringing the new cases under control is not the same as ending the pandemic. In the county I live in, we had new cases very much under control, but then the local governments bizarrely decided to reopen bars and sit-down restaurants, along with many other businesses, and predictably the cases almost immediately started spiking again. We're not done by a long shot. There's no quick fix.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by xyzzyz on Monday August 03, 2020 @09:33AM (#24037534)
I think the estimated threshold of 70% is way too high. That estimate is based on models that were shown to be wrong by empirical data we just observed. I think the herd immunity threshold is rather around 20-30%.

I think coming few months will prove me right: we will see more and more relaxation of lockdowns, without corresponding increase in cases, but only in places where the epidemics have already came on hard. Where it hasn’t been much of a thing, we will see many new cases and deaths, until those too will subside.

Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by _qulr on Saturday August 01, 2020 @03:46PM (#24023324)
Heh, someone downvoted me for posting facts in response to a false assertion. Gotta love HN.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by edanm on Saturday August 01, 2020 @04:06PM (#24023472)
I upvoted your previous comment, and it shouldn't have been downvoted. But please refrain from writing comments complaining about voting behavior - it's against the rules.
Re:The World’s Richest Families 2020 by glial on Saturday August 01, 2020 @11:09AM (#24021013)
Agree, at this point it seems like that’s the only thing that’s going to save us from a long drawn-out clusterfuck.