Re:Gleick's new book on information theory
by mckoss on Saturday April 02, 2011 @10:02PM
(#2401530)
Why did you find Chaos to be wonderful? I found many inaccuracies when I read it. Seemed more like a fluff piece designed to ride a popular wave about the topic at the time it came out.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Gleick's new book on information theory
by thaumaturgy on Sunday April 03, 2011 @12:44AM
(#2401835)
Do you always eat only the finest meals, freshly prepared, with only the highest-quality meats and produce?
Sometimes an In-n-Out burger can be "wonderful".
I, too, enjoyed Chaos. Regardless of its inaccuracies -- wherever they are -- it presents the topic very well, introducing it without being dry or unreadable. It held my attention throughout the book, and I still remember specific parts of it. I wouldn't mind reading it again, either.
Books, like business, can have different markets and do different things well. I think what Gleick lacks in writing a textbook, he makes up for in approachability.
Fair enough. I was just a bit surprised by the effusive comments on this thread when my experience was quite the opposite.
For my money, I've much more enjoyed the writings of Martin Gardner, or Bill Bryson.
if you like gardner and bryson, you should like ian stewart too
For me, perhaps it was my ignorance of the subject that both made me miss the book's inadequacies and made it seem wonderful to me. The concepts were new to me and were counter-intuitive in a mentally liberating way. It was also during a zeitgeist that produced books like The Tao of Physics.
Re:Gleick's new book on information theory
by mark_l_watson on Saturday April 02, 2011 @11:20PM
(#2401682)
A fair question but since I read the book back in 1988 all I can say from memory was that it got me excited about the field, using IFS, etc.