In the last month, for instance, I've purchased:
-- a pressure washer (had it in my garage within 90 mins of searching) -- an industrial grade hedge trimmer -- 4 dock floats -- a folding swimming ladder
The first three I found looking, the fourth I found by placing a "looking for" add myself.
Sure, I've had shitty experiences with Craigslist, by far the worst was when I was selling a truck. I had a lot of moronic callers and a couple of no-shows, but I also ended up selling it for good cash to a respectful guy.
The best bet in handling the bad parts was basically saying "sorry, not interested in selling it to you" when I get the sense that the other end of the call was a flake or not worth wasting time on. Sure, pissed off some of them, but I like to think I have a reasonable ability to read people, and wasn't desperate enough to sell the truck that I felt obligated to follow through with every potential buyer.
In the end, I'd rather deal with that crap than a dealership any day.
> And I even use it regularly to find stuff I want, locally, and cheap.
Are you really successful at that, though? 9 times out of 10 when I use craigslist the transaction is a horrible experience--for example:
The one area where I have had great success with craigslist is hiring, which I suspect is due to craigslist charging for job listings (which keeps the bar high).