Re:You don’t need SMS-2FA
by miohtama on Thursday July 30, 2020 @04:18PM
(#24002428)
The largest benefit of 2FA is that if your computer gets compromised it does not automatically to lead comprising of the online bank accounts and such. There still needs to be user interaction and a bot cannot read SMSes itself. Often this time window before a user is fooled is enough to neutralise the attack. It prevents massive user account compromise in scale.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That's not true for SMS-2FA, since text messages are often delivered to the device with the browser. Safari on both macOS and iOS will offer to automatically fill in the code received from SMS.
I am curious as to how Safari connects the 2FA code to the web page. It would seem whatever they are doing could easily implement a database that maps 2FA SMS messages to domains, not only refusing to auto enter them on phishing sites; but warning the user they may be on one.
Re:You don’t need SMS-2FA
by ThePowerOfFuet on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:18AM
(#24007574)
It doesn't; it offers to autofill a received code into a field on the page for a short time, but only actually fills it upon user interaction (so the page can't be sniffing for it via JS the moment it arrives).
But it is true for Windows PCs that represent more than 90% of compromised devices.
My Windows/Linux laptop has a SIM card slot
But I do not use it because of risk of getting 2FA compromised :/
Re:You don’t need SMS-2FA
by PopeDotNinja on Thursday July 30, 2020 @05:24PM
(#24002993)
That would be consistent with ~90% marketshare, wouldn't it?