Re:Dabblers and Blowhards - A Criticism of PG
by tptacek on Tuesday July 08, 2008 @02:04PM
(#240115)
I think he wrote carefully --- his critique is funny, a fast read, and works on multiple levels (as a parody of your writing style, as a reasoned criticism of your argument, and as a takedown of the cult of personality that surrounds you). I don't think either of your arguments are particularly careful anymore.
But you're right, if one chooses to be harshly analytical about your essay, it is indeed hard to pin you down to something that can be refuted directly.
Again: he wrote something clever and funny about you. You should be flattered. Right now, you really just seem petulant.
I notice now that you've finally produced a specific statement about painting that you claim he's refuted, though. And you are mistaken, as I think even you will have to agree. What I wrote was:
In other words, I am in fact saying that painters don't need to know a lot about paint chemistry, and using that as an analogy in statement that hackers, similarly, don't need to know much about the theory of computation.Is this finally starting to give you second thoughts about the idea that he's "carefully refuted" me?