One of the most important sets of principles the US founders relied on were the facts that power corrupts, that it (unfortunately) has to be wielded by someone in a governing sense, and that the best ways to keep government from becoming corrupt and abusive are to (a) limit its power to that which is essential for rule-of-law, representative government; and (b) divide that power among different people who have checks and balances on each others’ power.
Therefore it seems to me that a UBI is likely not a good idea because it vastly increases government’s power.
Note that the US government already wields a ton of power not explicitly granted by the constitution in the form of federal grants...
EDIT>> Also there is plenty of precedent for limiting things which are worded in such a way as to suggest they cannot be limited, eg: "shall not be infringed"
Welfare, on the other hand, is better understood and more narrowly focused. And even there you still have a ton of bullshit. I think UBI's deceptively simple yet vaguely broad scope will be tussled & twisted even more.
Beyond that, it's also ripe for political agitation because UBI would have fewer restrictions than welfare. You can already find provocative "news" segments about how disgraceful and undeserving welfare recipients are because they found one dude buying some crab meat or something using foodstamps. Imagine the outcry when people buy weed with UBI. The pressure to start policing and controlling UBI recipients would be enormous, even more than welfare which already has so many restrictions.
Yes, and it's only for humans too. Raccoons and shrubs don't receive the basic income.
I never thought of it evolving into different levels for different categories of people.
It's purely speculative FUD. It would be terrible if they did that, so make sure they don't. But it's a completely independent problem.
If that's the case, then I would personally feel the same way!
Not to make any argument for the feasibility of the idea, of course.
If people truly need to rely on the government for food, it would be absurdly inhumane of a society to let them starve.
Simultaneously, promoting reliance on the government and attempting to make that reliance universal has the potential to take away our freedoms.
Food stamps is an acceptable principle to Americans because it's meant to be temporary and need-based, and if you remove those two characteristics, it isn't just a reductio ad absurdum argument of taking the same concept further; it's entirely different.
https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/9/5/20849020/alaska-...
But I'll answer this anyway. UBI is unconditional. If a cash payment depends on the recipient's behaviour, it wouldn't be UBI. The same amount would be paid to everyone of working age.
Why mention China here? Something very similar happens in the UK with benefit sanctions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jobseeker%27s_Allowance#Sancti...
"...imagine how easy it would be for such a government that was also providing a basic income to its citizens to manipulate their citizens based on that basic income that they depended on. If they can deny citizens access to things like public transportation based on their ‘citizen score’, they can also deny those citizens (part of) their basic income depending on how ‘good’ their behavior is. So if you were too critical and thinking too independently, you could very easily be denied your basic income, and this could be a serious problem especially if you were brought up to be dependent on the government and to (heavily) rely on the income they provided."
More: https://blog.kareldonk.com/an-example-of-the-dangers-of-a-go...