Re:Speculation in JavaScriptCore
by pizlonator on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @03:28PM
(#23990653)
The post gives PyPy a shout out. But it’s subtle. PyPy is similar but not the same. I think that JSC’s exact technique could be tried for Python and I don’t believe it has.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Speculation in JavaScriptCore
by 1337shadow on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @03:32PM
(#23990690)
Maybe, I wish I had the occasion to deploy PyPy in production, but as a daily Python user since 2008: I never had to switch to PyPy to fix any performance problem that mattered for my users or me, but I keep an eye on PyPy and admire it as well as the developers behind it.
PyPy is faster than vanilla Python but it's not really built the same way as modern JavaScript engines and likely can't hit the same perf level.
What is the current development status of Pypy? I haven't heard much about it in the past couple years.
Python actually uses prototypal inheritance behind the scenes.
Pypy is a tracing JIT though which is quite different. JSC and v8 compile a method at a time. Spidermonkey used to use tracing, but switched to methods too (though I think it still does limited tracing in some situations).
Re:Speculation in JavaScriptCore
by jashmatthews on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @08:03PM
(#23992915)
TraceMonkey was removed almost a decade ago https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=698201
JaegerMonkey used both approaches. I don't know if IonMonkey still does though.
https://hacks.mozilla.org/2010/03/improving-javascript-perfo...
EDIT: It looks like a couple trace-like techniques are still used in IonMonkey (maybe the devs have some input there though).
Re:Speculation in JavaScriptCore
by jashmatthews on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @10:43PM
(#23993941)
There’s no tracing in either JägerMonkey or IonMonkey. That’s just a confusing statement about the similarity of speculation guards and OSR exits to trace guards and side exits. For a while TraceMonkey was used as a higher tier above JägerMonkey which might be what you’re thinking of?
I don’t work for Mozilla but spent a ton of time studying TraceMonkey for building my own tracing JIT.