News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I went with them and not you: feedback to an interviewer by jobeirne on Friday April 01, 2011 @11:05PM (#2398978)
Which "sweeping judgements" did I pass on people who do not prefer Unix? All I've said in this article is that, given the choice between Windows and Unix, I prefer Unix. I went on to add points on why I like Unix, which admittedly is a little extraneous, but I never voiced any negative judgement on Windows. Many seem to infer that themselves.
Re:Why I went with them and not you: feedback to an interviewer by delluminatus on Friday April 01, 2011 @11:15PM (#2399005)
Let's be honest, you were basically singing UNIX's praises for a little bit. While I agree with them, you have to admit that saying that "Unix encapsulates, and indeed was built on, many core principles of good software design" is a sidelong criticism of Windows which you imply is not built upon core principles of good software design. I imagine this could easily be construed as an insult.

Consider if a Windows user said he didn't want to work at a Unix shop because Windows is a better-designed operating system. Would you not consider this a judgement of Unix?

Re:Why I went with them and not you: feedback to an interviewer by jobeirne on Friday April 01, 2011 @11:41PM (#2399055)
Good points. I agree that it's reasonable to construe what I was saying as a swipe at Windows.

What I really meant, and I guess I didn't do a sufficient job at getting this across, was that I know Unix is rock-solid; I don't know the same about Windows. Truth be told, I know very little about Windows since I haven't used it for 4 years. I was going for a positive point about Unix, not a negative one about Windows.

But you have a pretty good point about my praise of Unix being a vacuous swipe at Windows.

Re:Why I went with them and not you: feedback to an interviewer by gridspy on Saturday April 02, 2011 @02:11AM (#2399352)
I only use Windows because I am always in too much of a rush to pass through the pain of adopting a new operating system on my desktop machine. We do deploy onto Linux.

I don't have any local Linux / Unix help.

Perhaps if you joined the team, many of the other developers would also have switched. I might have if I was from this company.

Re:Why I went with them and not you: feedback to an interviewer by dhume on Saturday April 02, 2011 @09:58AM (#2399898)
Consider if a Windows user said he didn't want to work at a Unix shop because Windows is a better-designed operating system. Would you not consider this a judgement of Unix?

Judgment of a platform and judgment of its users are separate issues.