Re:Ask HN: What is -2^2?
by laujen on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:40PM
(#2398934)
For the record, the TI-83 is -4 and the HP48 is 4. TI-83 (or now TI-84) is the dominant calculator in US math classes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: What is -2^2?
by yaks_hairbrush on Friday April 01, 2011 @11:21PM
(#2399016)
HP48 is RPN, which sidesteps precedence issues. So, here you explicitly need to decide if you want
2 NEG 2 ^ (i.e. (-2)^2) or
2 2 ^ NEG (i.e. -(2^2)).
The traditional order of operations is what the TI series does. In essence, it assumes you want the second form.
By the way, on my HP50G in algebraic mode, typing '-2^2' does give -4.
I apologize. You are correct, the HP48gx is RPN only. Don't know why I thought otherwise. I had it in my head for some reason that 48 did both (it kind of does but not really) and that it gave the answer as 4.