News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by analog31 on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @08:15PM (#23982123)
I learned to read at home, as did my parents, and my kids. My mom used what i think is called "phonics," where we learned the letters, then learned to sound out words. Written English isn't perfect, but it has a phonetic alphabet, suggesting a clue as to how reading works in a language with a phonetic alphabet.

Everybody I know who has taught their own kids uses phonics. Most don't use a manual or any special teaching materials other than starting with really easy words.

Now there's another factor as well: We learned to read without the stress and pressure of learning it in a classroom. We had time to break it up into tiny pieces throughout the day. I see parents out with their kids. They'll point to a sign, and say: "What's that word?"

Also, we were given time to read on our own rather than moving on to the next subject, because there were no other subjects at home.

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by bigiain on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @08:54PM (#23982362)
Heh. The first "product" I was ever technical lead on was a phonics based reading education "interactive CDROM" for children, a teaching course created by an educational psychologist as a reaction against the then-fashionable "holistic" method of teaching kids to read:

https://www.phonicsalive.com.au

We launched that in late 1995 scrambling to get it into shops for the xmas market and before schools closed for the year. We were significantly screwed over by changes in the multi track audio capabilities between Win3.3 and Windows95.

I'm inordinately proud that (at least some of them) are still for sale, and I break out into a huge smile every time I see a shelf full of them at a bricks and mortar retailer. Last time I checked (maybe 5 years back now) my name (and those of my team) were still printed around the edge of the CDROM.

(I'm also astounded it still works at all, and impressed by Microsoft's dedication to backwards compatibility. That was largely developed in MacOS9 and Windows 3.3 using Macromind (later Macromedia) Director. It stopped working on Mac back when Apple gave up on supporting running legacy MacOS9 apps and the owner/client didn't want to pay to upgrade for Mac. Now it's sold as "Windows only", but I'd bet pretty good money if you bought a copy and resurrected a MacOS9 machine, it'd still run just fine...)

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by spacephysics on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:03PM (#23982420)
If I’m not mistaken, I recall using your software to learn to read (rather my parents bought it for me). Many thanks! Now instead of reading just books I read code.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by bigiain on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:39PM (#23982657)
This also made me break out into a huge smile! Thank _you!_
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by axaxs on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @08:51PM (#23982341)
My daughter when learning to read used to just memorize what words looked like, which really frustrated me. So 'apply' is 'apple' because it looks like the memory word.

Anyhow, relevant part of my story, I taught her 100% with phonics post that point. In the above scenario, I might say 'wait there's a y there where did that go? sound it out slowly'. In no time she became a near perfect reader. I highly recommend the approach to anyone.

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by bigiain on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:10PM (#23982458)
I occasionally get to see a friend's ~7year old son practicing reading by reading out load. He obviously uses semantic cue to "assume" what a word is based on previous words, and occasionally gets a few words further then realises what he just said doesn't make sense, and he goes back and sounds out the incorrect work phonetically.

In this plague and WFH era, I've watched as the GoogleMeet live transcription does exalted the same sort of thing - it'll make a wrong word choice, then a few words later go back and correct itself based on grammar/syntax/context from subsequent words.

I sometimes wonder if that's an algorithm told to do something like "pick the highest priority word possibility that makes grammatical sense with all the previous words, if subsequent highest probability words then make the previous sentence fragment non grammatically correct, go back to previous words and try the next highest probability words to maximise grammatical correctness if the entire sentence so far" - or if it's just blackbox machine learned "magic" that happens to make similar mistakes and corrections as a sample 7 year old?

(Knowing Google, it's almost as likely that their algorithm is "keep building n-grams from each of the top n best-guesses of the previous y transcribed words, then count the number of times this each possible n-gram appears across the entire Google corpus of web pages, usenet, email, and google books, and pick the one with the highest historical use count"...)

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by 9nGQluzmnq3M on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:20PM (#23982531)
> live transcription does exalted the same sort of thing - it'll make a wrong word choice, then a few words later go back and correct itself based on grammar/syntax/context from subsequent words.

If only HN text input boxes were smart enough to do the same!

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by bigiain on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:37PM (#23982651)
Exactly!
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by jldugger on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @10:56PM (#23983122)
> count the number of times this each possible n-gram appears across the entire Google corpus

I mean, what you describe is basically a Markov Model described by Claude Shannon in his paper on entropy. Applying to speech recognition is pretty straightforward: As you keep speaking after a transcription mis-step, the odds that you said the thing becomes less and less likely given the words that followed it.

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by bhy on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @04:41AM (#23984588)
The algorithm, which works quite close to the way you described, is called "beam search": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beam_search
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by cardamomo on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @08:38PM (#23982255)
A good teacher in a school will also break up phonics instruction and weave it in throughout the day. The challenge of giving individual instruction to 20-35 students is monumental, though. Source: I'm a kindergarten and first grade teacher.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by opwieurposiu on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @11:42PM (#23983359)
You teach 30+ first graders solo? Each kid would get 2 minutes an hour. A close to impossible teaching task. Is that a normal teacher student ratio in your district? Is that normal for public school?
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by pfranz on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @01:07AM (#23983664)
Looking around in the US[1], it looks like legally the cap can be from 1:15 - 1:25 (K-3). It looks like 1/3 of states don't have any legal cap. Funny enough, this chart[2] correlating reading performance and class size stops at 1:21 for 4th and 8th grade.

[1] http://ecs.force.com/mbdata/MBQuest2RTanw?rep=KK3Q1807

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student%E2%80%93teacher_ratio#...

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by tasogare on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @12:26AM (#23983507)
This is the norm almost everywhere worldwide.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by analog31 on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @01:57AM (#23983842)
Indeed, my kindergarten class was 36 kids.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by underwater on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @11:01PM (#23983145)
My kids are both strong readers, but took different paths.

The first taught herself to read before she started school. On day one the teacher tested her and she could read the first 200 words they were to be taught. She had had support and encouragement from us, and we read to her every night, but we never did any structured lessons with her

The second couldn't read when she started school, and was taught using phonics. It took a couple of months for it to click, but then she was getting letter sounds, understanding digraphs, joining sounds together, and then reading words. When she got to that point she just took off.

I feel like our first would have succeeded in the American system just fine. But the second really benefitted from laying that groundwork that let her understand the fundamentals. If she'd learned using the three cues system I feel like her self-directed progress would have been much slower.

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by elihu on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @09:25PM (#23982568)
I don't remember exactly how I learned to read, but it seems very strange to me that anyone would try to teach someone to read English without teaching them the sounds that the letters make.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by sergers on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @02:16AM (#23983920)
I am sure they have changed curriculum overs years, but I was born in 86 west coast canada.

I learned using phonics.

We have been introducing our daughter to phonics for a few months now (16 months old).

I am suprised to read in this article that it's not part of American curriculum... very strange indeed.

Every toy, video, for english alphabet we have/seen has a phonics component

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by jimmaswell on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @08:51PM (#23982346)
Was it "Hooked on Phonics"? That's what I had and my reading was apparently very above average.
Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by analog31 on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @12:07AM (#23983434)
It was in the late 1960s. I grew up near Detroit. We had visited the Henry Ford Museum where they had reprints of the classic McGuffy's Reader, mentioned in the article. We just went through that book. As others have mentioned, at some point it "clicked" and I needed no further instruction.

Like programming. ;-)

My mom also made a big deal of going to the library every week, like it was some kind of amazing sanctuary, which of course it was.

Now an odd thing I remember is that my office mate in grad school listened to the Rush Limbaugh Program, and the two advertisers I remember were Snapple and Hooked on Phonics. Funny what things we remember.

Re:How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor... by Someone on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#23990638)
“Written English isn't perfect, but it has a phonetic alphabet“

What do you mean by “phonetic alphabet?” I thought the correlation between spelling and pronunciation is extremely weak in English. See for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chaos