One of the key points the article makes is that a "balanced literacy" approach doesn't work. A footnote explains:
> "If children are taught systematic phonics in one part of the reading program but are encouraged to use context to guess at words when reading passages, they may not apply their phonics skills consistently. Thus, the phonics component of the reading program may be undermined." — from The Use of Context Cues in Reading.[1]
I'm not sure why you think there shouldn't be best practices in reading education. Certain methods will outperform others. Why shouldn't we identify and refine the methods that prove to work best?
1. https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-ho...
Some students are strong with vocab, others with grammar. Some with listening, others with speaking. Some with oral, some with written. I could go on and on with 20 other different things.
Education experts do attempt to identify and refine the methods that prove to work best, but real-world teachers know that those methods come in waves, fads of academia, and that a teacher needs to know the basics of all methods, combined with the strengths and weaknesses of their students, and use their intuition to try to come up with a good combination.
So it's less about a "balanced" approach, and more of a "try everything and see what sticks with any individual student" approach.
Because here's what does work: let students build core competency around wherever their natural strengths are, and then they'll eventually get the other stuff.
But the idea that "certain methods will outperform others" is grossly simplistic. Sure there are some dumb methods that don't work for anybody but those get quickly discarded. Of the rest, even if a method outperforms in the aggregate, it's going to be terribly underperforming for a significant proportion of students.
Remember, phonics gives immediate improvements too, for short words. So it's pretty much a false dichotomy.
For students who are picking up phonics quickly from the start, great. For the students who are struggling from the start, try other methods ASAP.
As a teacher, figuring out which methods work for a student isn't rocket science. Your students are either getting better on a visible daily basis or not. We're not talking a 5% difference in outcomes, it's more like 75% difference. (Of course, bad teachers just don't pay attention at all, or are too swamped with work to be able to.)
On the flip side I agree that only doing phonics might be a local maximum for the group.
I called out the term "best practices" because it's often used to refer to pedagogy that is no longer supported by the research. I suspect this is the case in other fields as well: the so-called best practices we espouse are more a function of the values of our workplace or work community than anything else.
Moreover, I think when teachers feel forced to adopt a teaching method they dislike, their enthusiasm flags, and teacher enthusiasm is something that has a big impact on learning (I'd be interested to hear if anyone disputes the idea that miserable or apathetic teachers result in less effective teaching)
I think the most effective approach to this kind of research is a toolkit approach, where teachers adjust their teaching methods using different well-developed practices based on experience, different aspects of the student population, and the teacher's knowledge / enthusiasm for a specific technique.
EDIT (just adding on): It's clear to me from my experience that there is not one single way children learn to read. That much should be obvious to anyone who spends a lot of time with young children, but the field of education clings to the idea of "best practices."
Second, a lot of our practices in the U.S. still stem from the National Reading Panel, which was convened nearly 20 (!) years ago as part of No Child Left Behind. Yet it's easy to find criticisms of the report the Panel issued. Just Google it. Here's a good one to start with: https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2003/04/30/33yatvin.h22.h...