> They are therefore not a substitute for basic hygiene measures and physical distancing, where possible and practical.
That was the strongest wording "against" that I saw. And that is the typical "no evidence" disclaimer, not an evidence of no proof or evidence of harm.
Your post is misleading. It takes a bulletin from a country where COVID had been essentially eliminated, and implied that it's guidelines are appropriate for others where infection is rampant.
https://www.health.govt.nz/system/files/documents/pages/revi...
But, listen, if you have better information, I'm all ears. The whole point is to be directed by science, and right now, you're not going to find hard science, i.e., RCTs, to support the prevailing policies.
From the page you link > This advice on use of face masks in the community will be updated if new evidence or guidance from the World Health Organization emerges, or we see a change in COVID-19 disease patterns in New Zealand (for example, increasing community transmission).
So they are simply not advocating masks due to low community transmission.
My main counter claim to the top-level comment is that the messaging is not uniform.
As an example, I've pointed out that policy differs between neighboring areas, and, indeed, policy differs from science.
There is an entire section of the attached material under the heading "Risks and pitfalls." I didn't write it, so forgive me if I'm not too upset that people don't like it.
EDIT: For the record, I'm not angry :)
Tl;dr: When both parties wear marks, both cloth and N95 masks are likely sufficient for mitigating infections in enclosed spaces.
How’s this for science: look at the statistics for nations which had near-100% mask compliance (Taiwan, SK, Japan).
Look at the animal study on hamsters separated by walls made of surgical masks.
The resistance to masks in the US is just insanity.
Check the average daily ridership every month, compare against the previous year. No matter what else they do, they're still on the trains. Even in the worst months, 2/3rds as many rides were taken. Social distancing? Psh.
If you're curious, NY MTA reports -75% right now. That's right. Taipei -33% at worst, NY MTA -75%. Which city was worse hit? Which city was hit first? Which city was closer?
Masks are certainly a part of of it, but I wouldn't assign the entire impact to them.
“Healthy members of the public may choose to purchase and wear a face mask, or make their own.“
Scandinavia is not a unified political entity. US in-fighting more worrying than funny.
Unless I am mistaken, NZ did not ask (=require) the general public to wear masks because the NZ government was primarily following information disseminated through the WHO as guidance.
That is my understanding also. And now the WHO has (after many months of proclaiming masks as useless) turned around and started advocating for them. The WHO also denied that COVID-19 was a pandemic far beyond the point where it was clearly exploding in many regions, while insisting that all airline flights should continue as normal, and probably contributed significantly to the speed and scale of the global pandemic by doing so.
I wouldn't place any credence in old WHO statements regarding this virus (or, honestly, in anything the WHO says after their performance here).
Scandinavia can't agree on policies. Americans are physically fighting each other over it, in probably the funniest overt display of criminal obedience.
It was fomites, so don't touch anything, and don't touch your face. Now there are no fomites, and definitely put a dirty rag on your face at all times.
I'd go back to 9/11 over this cluster fuck in a heartbeat.