News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quiet route planning for pedestrians in traffic noise pol... by boxcardavin on Monday July 27, 2020 @03:13PM (#23968369)
Ebikers naturally start taking routes that optimize for safety and enjoyment over avoiding hills. It would be cool for Strava or Goog Maps to detect ebikers (easy to tell from speed vs road grade) and weight their routes more heavily in deciding the best route to recommend.
Re:Quiet route planning for pedestrians in traffic noise pol... by bobthepanda on Monday July 27, 2020 @03:48PM (#23968710)
Even better than just trying to detect it via ML, let it be a separate option to toggle.
Re:Quiet route planning for pedestrians in traffic noise pol... by bdamm on Monday July 27, 2020 @05:00PM (#23969322)
Still need ML to build the menu of paths.
Re:Quiet route planning for pedestrians in traffic noise pol... by bobthepanda on Monday July 27, 2020 @05:46PM (#23969784)
Sure, but

> to detect ebikers (easy to tell from speed vs road grade) and weight their routes more heavily in deciding the best route to recommend.

seems like an anti-pattern that screws over people who don't have e-bikes.

If users can tell us that they're using an e-bike and we give a separate option then both e-bikers and pedalers can have navigation options that work best for the specific use case, rather than shoehorning both into the same option.

We need to stop assuming things using ML and pretend like that's somehow more user-friendly than the user directly telling us what they want. (See: constant griping about how poorly non-verbatim Google search is getting)