News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cracking down on research fraud by moralestapia on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:58PM (#23961659)
>labs operate largely as fiefdoms of the individual principal investigators

To add to the injury, you wouldn't believe the extent of the actions to which some PIs become engaged in order to attain/preserve their 'power'. Illegal, unethical and pathetic.

The core problem is that PIs are human, and humans are flawed. The solution (if there is one) should take this into account, and somehow try to reduce it systematically, at an institutional level. The problem is that the ones that make the rules are not going to fight against themselves ... I wish I had something more to add, but that's it, that's the state of the field.

Re:Cracking down on research fraud by rscho on Monday July 27, 2020 @03:38AM (#23962971)
> The core problem is that PIs are human

Actually, the problematic behaviours you describe are encouraged at the institutional level, because institutions also get more funding if they output more/better research. The fact that postdocs don't want to commit scientific suicide for the sake of morals in that context should surprise no one.

The ground truth is that scientific research has been turned into a poorly regulated industry, and we are all poorer for it.

There's a very simple solution to alleviate this pain: be much more selective starting at the undergrad level. But that generates less money, so baaaaad...

Re:Cracking down on research fraud by moralestapia on Monday July 27, 2020 @12:43PM (#23966789)
>[...] the problematic behaviours you describe are encouraged at the institutional level

Yes, which is why I wrote,

>[...] and somehow try to reduce it systematically, at an institutional level.

Re:Cracking down on research fraud by rapjr9 on Monday July 27, 2020 @07:58PM (#23970764)
This is also why you see announcements of new "breakthroughs" and then nothing further ever happens. The experience is so unpleasant for many people (often compared to slavery) that they leave when they get their degree and never work on that project again. The PI's also get bored and want to do something new to keep building their reputation (so onward to the next grad student or post doc). Patents are sometimes generated, but new ideas are very difficult to take to market successfully so those that can afford to buy or license them do so very carefully (unless they want the patent to attack some competitors product.) In general there is rarely any follow through on new ideas, unless you work on projects with DARPA funding where they insist on "technology transfer", and even then many ideas turn out to be unworkable because they require additional extensive engineering for the practical aspects.