Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Grit Has a Negligible Effect on Success Compared to Intelligence. Parent comment
I agree your original comment used the conditional ‘if’ about the truth of fixed intelligence.
Such a proposition naturally invites examination of whether the conditions are in supported by evidence, which is all I am doing.
I am curious if you have a definition of intelligence that sheds light on your original argument.
I have no stake in what truth you believe.
However I think your argument is clearly incorrect.
As you suggest, I could be basing my conclusion on a different definition to the one you are using.
But if you won’t produce a clarifying definition, you can’t reasonably make claim to be operating under any principle of cooperation.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
I agree your original comment used the conditional ‘if’ about the truth of fixed intelligence.
Such a proposition naturally invites examination of whether the conditions are in supported by evidence, which is all I am doing.
I am curious if you have a definition of intelligence that sheds light on your original argument.
I have no stake in what truth you believe.
However I think your argument is clearly incorrect.
As you suggest, I could be basing my conclusion on a different definition to the one you are using.
But if you won’t produce a clarifying definition, you can’t reasonably make claim to be operating under any principle of cooperation.