News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:38AM (#23956030)
Because the alternative is unrest, instability, and eventually mass death. It's hard to have a "competitive" economy when you've trashed your civilisation.

It takes a while, but that's the predictable final outcome of failing to remove the carbon that is causing climate change.

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by baron_harkonnen on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:15AM (#23957628)
Look at how well the US (and other countries) has handled pandemic. Pandemic is basically a toy-problem version of climate change:

- Action must be taken before you see consequences

- The best time to act is right away, though it might not seem a big deal if you do

- You need to trust experts

- Taking some initial economic damage is unavoidable...

- ... but is ultimately much cheaper than not taking that hit

- strong leadership and a unified population is needed to align interests and create mutually beneficial cooperation

etc, etc.

But the US failed spectacularly, and most importantly learned nothing from it.

If we can’t control pandemic easily we are certainly going to fail to make any progress on global warming

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by perfunctory on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:44AM (#23956056)
I am not questioning the fact that we should transition to the zero-carbon economy and remove excess carbon from the atmosphere. I am just saying that in my view CCS is not the most efficient way to achieve it.
Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by DennisP on Sunday July 26, 2020 @10:03AM (#23957114)
You might be right, and if we enact a carbon price that gives credit for CCS, the market will do a good job at figuring out what's most efficient for any given situation.
Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by hedora on Sunday July 26, 2020 @11:15AM (#23957625)
The most efficient way to do it is to forcibly remove every politician that opposes reducing CO2.

CCS is more likely to succeed and will lead to significantly less bloodshed than overthrowing all the governments at once.

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by perfunctory on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:38PM (#23958252)
> The most efficient way to do it is to forcibly remove every politician that opposes reducing CO2.

And how would you go about doing that? I am genuinely curious. Do you know of any organisation that is going to do the forcing? I would be happy to donate. Or do you know a way I can do forcible removal myself without risking my life?

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by hedora on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:51PM (#23958338)
I don’t think anyone has a good way to fix all the governments at the same time. The climate summits seem like a joke.

If you’re in the US, vote this fall, and hope the Democrats make good on their campaign promises.

It’s better than nothing.

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by cryoshon on Sunday July 26, 2020 @12:32PM (#23958206)
agreed entirely.

there's no way forward regarding global warming with the current US insitution of leadership, comprised of both major parties. they've got to be removed for the most optimal response to climate change, but doing so will be ghastly.

that's why i've started hunting for CCS solutions/companies to invest in/ways to start a company to leverage CCS for profit. we're going to need a massive mop to clean up the mess the baby boomers are still insisting on making worse.

Re:What if carbon removal becomes the new Big Oil? by jacobush on Sunday July 26, 2020 @06:44AM (#23956055)
So, it’s pretty strong bet on unrest and instability then, I guess.