News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by ed25519FUUU on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:14AM (#23949773)
As someone who has advocated for strong states rights (a position that’s traditionally not held by the progressive left over the last decade) I find these times to be interesting, and full of ideological dissonance.

People are asking for a federal mandate on masks, but at the same time want no federal enforcement of these laws? How about neither?

I hate seeing a world where “federal police” come in and squash local protests, and it bugs me that previously state rights advocates are calling for it.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by zo1 on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:27AM (#23949884)
I think it's safe to say that political discourse and the possibility of any societal-level discussion (and agreement) has failed. It's the same crap that plagues software development when modelling complex business problems. Political or decision makers never ask explicit questions (like yours), make decisions (laws) on them and then follow through without hesitation.

Here we are in 2020 and we've got camps trying to justify how violent protests are a "civil rights" or "free speech" issue instead of just agreeing and everyone saying "yeah - anyone can protest because we agree it's a right, but police can arrest anyone that does violence". We're forever complicating and conflating issues, adding layer upon layer of complexity, instead of simplifying. I think the analogy to software development is quite profound.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by aww_dang on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:21AM (#23949830)
This is typical of today's divisive atmosphere. Do you remember the other BLM (Bureau of Land Management) protests in Oregon?

I recall outraged partisans demanding federal intervention, while claiming that the ranchers were enjoying special privileges due to their race. I believe they called them "vanilla ISIS".

Of course individuals within any movement will vary, but generally speaking, partisans want to use the power of the state against their ideological opponents. When it is used against them, they predictably cry foul.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by chowells on Saturday July 25, 2020 @01:47PM (#23951056)
Do you actually believe that graffiti and a couple small fires rise to the same level of criminality as an armed takeover of federal land? It's fully possible to believe the federal government should put a stop to armed takeovers of federal land and not be involved in graffiti on non-federal property without it being a partisan thing.

The problem is that people believe the protests in Portland are violent riots. They aren't. As long as people are manipulated so easily, I guess real policy discussions aren't going to happen.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by aww_dang on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:11PM (#23954119)
I'm not looking for equivalency in that sense. On one hand you have arsonists seeking to destroy federal property. On the other you had armed (not specifically violent) men occupying federal property. One of these men was shot.

The equivalence is the partisan hypocrisy. There are several sources citing violence in Portland. Even left leaning sources acknowledge this.

When you dismiss someone's view you disagree with as "manipulated", you illustrate the larger point I was making.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by NPMaxwell on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:55AM (#23950114)
I think maybe the issue here is that the press did not cover the unidentified federal agents arresting the BLM protesters. The result is that it looks like the treatment of the Portland protesters is different.
Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by treeman79 on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:32AM (#23949924)
Ban the police crowd is the weirdest thing.

No police means maximum freedom quickly followed by complete Anarchy. Then back to some sort of restrictive government.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by rsynnott on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:50AM (#23950061)
Most people aren’t suggesting literally banning the police, but rather either decapitating and reorganising (RUC would be an example) or dissolving and replacing wholesale (Stasi would be an example).
Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by ed25519FUUU on Saturday July 25, 2020 @12:22PM (#23950364)
I feel like this argument is an example of gaslighting. The people who are calling to defund the police literally mean defunding the police.

Presumably the ones that make this call are hoping an ideological paramilitary arm (such as antifa) can fill the power vacuum left behind.

Those that want reform are asking for reform.

Don’t be gaslit.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by megameter on Saturday July 25, 2020 @12:55PM (#23950650)
Gaslighting occurs with respect to a current situation, not a hypothetical.

Here are top results on Google for "defund the police."

“Defund the police” means reallocating or redirecting funding away from the police department to other government agencies ...

“Defund the police” means reallocating or redirecting funding away from the police department to other government agencies funded by the local municipality.

"Defund the police" is a slogan that supports divesting funds from police departments and reallocating them to non-policing forms of public safety and community support, such as social services, youth services, housing, education, healthcare and other community resources.

Instead of funding a police department, a sizable chunk of a city's budget is invested in communities, especially marginalized ...

Police abolition means reducing, with the vision of eventually eliminating, our reliance on policing to secure our public safety. It ...

No sources in these results say "create a power vacuum". That is the invention of critics. Please demonstrate otherwise.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by treeman79 on Saturday July 25, 2020 @05:09PM (#23952447)
Google is extremely political. Search results are not trustworthy on anything political.
Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by sangnoir on Saturday July 25, 2020 @01:25PM (#23950883)
You don't need to presume; just read their platform. They want the police to stop filling the vacuum left by lack of social services (i.e. police currently respond to people mental distress because there are no social workers who currently do that). They want to defund the police and have the money directed to social services so that police stop being a jack of all trades (especially since they are not trained in deescalation).

Public education has been defunded for decades, but we still have teachers and public schools, and their charter alternatives - that should be your mental model not abolishment of police.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by rsynnott on Saturday July 25, 2020 @04:43PM (#23952241)
As far as I know, essentially everyone is either asking for either "in some way reorganise this, maybe lose the leadership, or at most fire the lot and make a new one" or "pull money and responsibilities from this and give to social services/community groups/whatever". However, those make for awful slogans. "Defund the police" is a good slogan.

This is, incidentally, probably the US left learning the Hillary Clinton Lesson. Detailed, costed proposals of what you want to do may be very practical, but people prefer a good slogan, and to leave the details to the detail people.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by dragonwriter on Saturday July 25, 2020 @04:57PM (#23952358)
> The people who are calling to defund the police literally mean defunding the police.

The people who are saying defund the police do want that literally, but they don't mean “reduce funding to zero”, they mean reduce funding and responsibility and transfer the bits that aren't optimally served by an armed paramilitary law enforcement force to be served by other agencies, who also get the associated funding.

There are people who take that a step further, who prefer the slogan “dismantle the police” or “abolish the police”. Mostly, like the “defund” group with which they overlap (these are variations rather than strict alternatives) they want to fund agencies that they see as more appropriate for the functions, but the dismantle/abolish group thinks that the kind of centralized armed groups with paramilitary organization that exist as local police departments aren't the right solution to any problems (except perhaps for large scale civil disorder, but we already have the national guard to respond to that, who don't do nearly as much to provoke that disorder in the first place), so they think all the functions of existing police departments should be transferred to other agencies (some of which might have arrest powers, and even armed agents, but those agents would be working for domain-specific agencies, not a massive centralized general-purpose paramilitary law enforcement agency.)

> Presumably the ones that make this call are hoping an ideological paramilitary arm (such as antifa) can fill the power vacuum left behind.

No, for the most part the defund/dismantle/abolish group thinks that the problem is centralized omnipresent paramilitary forces with a separate ideology and culture from the general society, not that we just need to swap one out for a different one.

> Those that want reform are asking for reform.

“Defund the police” and “dismantle/abolish the police” are approaches to reform of how society serves the functions currently served by the police. They are approaches differing from the counterproductive “reform” efforts that have led us where we are today because they don't involve shoveling more scarce resources and more responsibility into local centralized paramilitary law enforcement agencies.

Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by ed25519FUUU on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:33AM (#23949927)
If anything, that gives the federal police more power, to come in and fill the void “to ensure domestic tranquility”.
Re:Homeland Security Was Destined to Become a Secret Police ... by defnotashton2 on Saturday July 25, 2020 @01:45PM (#23951038)
There is no void. The movements still result in that service filled just with a different face. Essentially rebuild with less horizontal expectations and power, creating sister organizations that are scoped to their appropriate need.

Maybe that means having a deescalation officer lead to thugs around I'm not sure but it's not have no police force.