News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by 082349872349872 on Saturday July 25, 2020 @04:11AM (#23947569)
A friend of mine once asked his TA about (my memory fails here) either how to activate a leaving group or set up a protecting group at a given hypothetical structure. The TA, without batting an eyelid, responded "I think you'll find all the precursors are scheduled, too." The next lab, the TA, presumably having reflected a bit and in the middle of an unrelated discourse, added "remember, always characterise any synthesis you undertake."

Edit: (ratelimit, sorry)

group: small chemical structure manipulated in a single synthetic step. See also

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaving_group

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protecting_group

scheduling: I have no idea, but it seems likely that at least all the easy precursors were. (ChemE, like systems CS, is all about tradeoffs. It's unlikely anyone bothers to schedule precursors along very difficult synthetic routes. Just like CS people have the IOCCC, synthetic chemists sometimes do small batches with pathways no ChemE would use, just because they're there.)

characterisation: One should do this anyways, to discover if what one has made is what one had intended to make. (compare with unit testing) In the context, I'd consider it a warning that one should especially do this if one plans to partake product.

TA: teaching assistant (post- or just pre-MS in this case, definitely with lab experience)

The punchline is that the TA could guess the intended product given only a single synthesis step for a partial structure. (To be fair, computer geeks love discussing black hat activities, so it shouldn't be any surprise chemists are up on the "abuses" of their science to the same degree.)

Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by jacobush on Saturday July 25, 2020 @04:57AM (#23947741)
What is a group? (Group of people, or some chemical compound, or some kind of corporate structure, protecting possibly illegal stuff going on in one of the groups?)

Are all the precursors scheduled, or is the punchline that the TA was wrong?

Why would one do well to remember to characterise any synthesis undertaken? To protect oneself against legal action by showing that the labs purpose was synthesising legal compounds?

Is "TA" the same as Tax Attorney?

Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by Anthony-G on Saturday July 25, 2020 @07:05AM (#23948282)
Upvoted because these are good questions, indicating a genuine willingness to understand exactly what another poster is saying. That’s the kind of discussion that I come to Hacker News for. Not everyone has the same background and understanding of terminology and they shouldn’t be down-voted for that.
Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by dekhn on Saturday July 25, 2020 @09:41AM (#23949089)
A "group" is a bundle of atoms that hangs off the side of a core structure, typically. http://www.chem.ucla.edu/~harding/IGOC/G/group.html

When you do a reaction on a chemical, the reaction can often affect multiple different parts of the structure, even if you only want it to affect one site. So, you can pop a "protecting group" onto the site you don't want modified, and then remove it later. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protecting_group

A TA is a teaching assistant; typically a grad student with lots of knowledge teaching a class to undergrads.

You would want to characterize any synthesis- verify your work to make sure you got high quality product that is pure.

Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by monkeycantype on Saturday July 25, 2020 @09:27AM (#23949015)
The 'groups' are chemical structures present in a compound. The student asks the Teaching Assistant (typically a graduate student who is required to do teach) a general question about how to carry out a multi step process to selectively transform specific regions of chemical compounds.

The punchline is that the Teaching Assistant immediately sees the intent of the question, and goes from the general to the specific and replies: [ you won't be able to synthesise LSD with that approach because ] "all of the precursors are also scheduled."

Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by echelon on Saturday July 25, 2020 @09:44AM (#23949108)
Leaving groups are the part of the molecule that are designed to "leave" during a particular reaction

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaving_group

You design your synthesis around this and try to pick pathways that are easy, have the highest yields, and don't produce undesirable products you have to remove.

Re:LSD Chemist William Pickard to Be Released from Prison by gspr on Saturday July 25, 2020 @05:16AM (#23947806)
I'm guessing TA is teaching assistant.