Re:A gem of a legal opinion spanking a lawyer for a frivolou...
by tzs on Thursday March 31, 2011 @01:25PM
(#2392536)
When reading this, be aware it is a ruling on a motion by the defendant for a summary judgement. Informally, the defendant is essentially saying "even if every fact the plaintiff claims is true, he has no case".
That's why the court says this: "In setting forth the facts underlying this dispute, the Court draws exclusively from Plaintiff’s version of events, resolving all disputed facts in Plaintiff’s favor and assuming without deciding that Defendants’ evidentiary objections are to be overruled". If one misses that it is a summary judgement motion, it might look like the court is unfairly favoring plaintiff.
Edit: also note that the $750 fee the plaintiff paid to register his copyright is not normal. Copyright registration is normally $35 dollars. That's what you would pay as a US author, registering your work before publication so that you can recover damages from US infringers. (Foreign authors do not have to register to recover damages from US infringers in US courts, which is why this registration requirement does not violate US obligations under the Berne Convention).
The only $750 registration I see on the copyright office's fee schedule is for registration with expedited processing. That generally means plaintiff fucked up. :-)
That's why the court says this: "In setting forth the facts underlying this dispute, the Court draws exclusively from Plaintiff’s version of events, resolving all disputed facts in Plaintiff’s favor and assuming without deciding that Defendants’ evidentiary objections are to be overruled". If one misses that it is a summary judgement motion, it might look like the court is unfairly favoring plaintiff.
Edit: also note that the $750 fee the plaintiff paid to register his copyright is not normal. Copyright registration is normally $35 dollars. That's what you would pay as a US author, registering your work before publication so that you can recover damages from US infringers. (Foreign authors do not have to register to recover damages from US infringers in US courts, which is why this registration requirement does not violate US obligations under the Berne Convention).
The only $750 registration I see on the copyright office's fee schedule is for registration with expedited processing. That generally means plaintiff fucked up. :-)