Wireguard is just a better wire protocol for moving packets, but IMO it's mostly a solution in search of a problem. Most of the complexity that people disdain about IPSec actually comes from IKE, but it's largely irreducible complexity. IKE is what initiates and negotiates security associations based on abstract flow rules--in this case 0.0.0.0/0 <-> W.X.Y.Z, where the latter is the static, routable address. Wireguard doesn't diminish the need for this layer, which is why you've been forced to hack a complete solution using a reverse proxy. IKE is far more mature than the experimental additional software Wireguard developers have been cooking up to automate tasks like this (abstract flows, key management, etc), and definitely more mature than the homebrew solutions people put together.
I bring this up because I think IPSec has gotten an undeserved bad rap. If people make do with Wireguard + hacks, great, but this particular scenario is a great example that shows the strengths of IPSec+IKE and the weakness of Wireguard; a reality people don't hear about given the unabashed enthusiasm for Wireguard.
To give my home router a static IP address, I use a Vultr VPS and pay for an additional IP address. I then use IPSec encapsulation to forward traffic for the second IP address directly to the router, which initiates the IPSec SA setup. The router has a loopback device configured with the static IP address; the routable static address is effectively local, even from the kernel's perspective. The IPSec rules handle forwarding of everything, so I don't even need packet filtering (e.g. OpenBSD PF in my case) rules.
No need to fiddle with private address ranges, NAT'ing, reverse proxying, or packet filtering of any sort. The IKEv2 setup is a single line on the VPS and a single line on the router, though OpenBSD's OpenIKED (as well as their isakmpd fork for IKEv1) is awesome that way; StrongSwan and other Linux IKE daemons require a more verbose configuration on account of their key-value pair syntax, but in any event it's still relatively simple.