https://www.google.com/books/edition/_/d4YUZVq1JSEC?hl=en&gb...
The first line, "I won't say anything which anyone can dispute" is from Lecture 2.
The next two lines ("I understand but I don't agree" / "Turing doesn't object") are from Lecture 6.
The "I see your point" / "I have no point" was a remark amid a deeper conversation during Lecture 10.
Juxtaposing the lines like this makes Wittgenstein seem comically insane (which is the joke, and I do get it).
And then he proceeds to play the language game he said he is going to play given his interpretation of the rules he set forth.
It's the rule-following paradox in practice.
"This was our paradox: no course of action could be determined by a rule, because any course of action can be made out to accord with the rule"
He's taking the piss of axiomatic/formal reasoning which is the epitome of pointless rule-following.I find the unreasonable effectiveness of formal systems to be this: just as the shaman crosses into the "spirit world" and uses their experience there to predict happenings in our world, we can turn statements about bridges and dynamic loads in our world into formal statements, arrangements of symbols, and manipulate them mindlessly according to a formal system, yet the resulting safety margins do indeed predict happenings in our world.
(A city once gave an engineering school the contract to demolish an old bridge. The date was agreed upon, but that afternoon the city had to sent representatives out at lunchtime to insist that even though it hadn't been formally specified in the contract, their intent —and the neighbour's expectations— had always been that the bridge would be blown up all at once, not that little bits be blown off all morning to see how much structure could be removed before collapse...)
The Wikipedia article [0] does a better job of explaning it than I could.
Perhaps you haven't noticed that this technique can be applied to your own narratives/beliefs? Because your beliefs are inconsistent too.
Everybody's beliefs are inconsistent - it's a systemic issue. We know about it. The root cause is the fact that language is recursive and it succumbs to Russel's paradox/liar's paradox.
Philosophers have been using inconsistency as a crutch for guilting people into changing their minds for... ever.
Do I contradict myself? Very well, then I contradict myself, I am large, I contain multitudes. --Walt WhitmanHe was good at pointing out problems. The rest of his work consisted of hand-waving.