News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Twitter Hack by sanderjd on Monday July 20, 2020 @09:11PM (#23903479)
I really feel like everyone is getting one of the broad points in this discussion wrong. If Twitter is a national security risk because people can hack it to speak in the official voice of prominent leaders, or discover state secrets through direct messages, that is nobody's fault but the government's, for relying on a platform they have no control over for official business.

Can you imagine the military complaining that the enemy was able to give false orders or discover troop movements through messages on a privately owned communications network completely outside their control? No, because it would be absurd for the military to rely on such a network. It is no less absurd that the civilian government (which nominally has more power than the military) is doing so.

It was a scandal when Hillary Clinton relied on a private email server. It is a far larger scandal that so many leaders, and especially the President, are now relying on a private company for their official communications.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by chasing on Monday July 20, 2020 @09:43PM (#23903639)
Obviously government employees shouldn't be using Twitter DMs for unofficial business, but they're more or less required to use Twitter for communications with the public and fundraising. If they don't, they hand way too much of an edge to their competitors. The issue is that we don't want Donald Trump to mysteriously tweet "We're nuking Toronto this afternoon! #MAGA" and have a national security episode trying to figure out if it's a hacker or if he just saw something on Fox News that irked him.
Re:On the Twitter Hack by sanderjd on Monday July 20, 2020 @10:57PM (#23903948)
They would not be "required" to use Twitter to keep up with their competitors, if they were all required not to use it for official communications. I'm not saying that politicians should choose to stop using Twitter for official communications, I'm saying Congress should pass a law requiring they not. I think there are already laws on the books around appropriate changes for official communications that could be augmented for this purpose.
Re:On the Twitter Hack by anonbcpolitics on Monday July 20, 2020 @10:02PM (#23903720)
> If Twitter is a national security risk because people can hack it to speak in the official voice of prominent leaders, or discover state secrets through direct messages, that is nobody's fault but the government's, for relying on a platform they have no control over for official business.

I don't see the government relying on it. I see public officials using it as a platform. No coordination is being done (unless it's redundancy), just communication with constituents.

> It was a scandal when Hillary Clinton relied on a private email server.

One problem with using a private email server was because it circumvented FOIA requests. Twitter is open, a private email server is not. We still don't know what 33k of the subpoenaed emails were about that her personal IT guy deleted, other than the ones found on Huma Abedin's laptop.

The other problem of course is having a personal IT staff run your email server with classified secrets (yes there were classified emails). It's not quite the same as having Twitter or the DoD run your security. I mean, the guy (stonetear) was on Reddit asking how to delete emails, I doubt he knew how to protect against state actors.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by burkaman on Monday July 20, 2020 @11:01PM (#23903963)
> I don't see the government relying on it. I see public officials using it as a platform. No coordination is being done (unless it's redundancy), just communication with constituents.

The president regularly announces decisions on Twitter that he has not communicated through any other medium. Here's two major examples:

https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/13/17113950/trump-state-depa...

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/01/donald-...

Re:On the Twitter Hack by EvanAnderson on Monday July 20, 2020 @11:30PM (#23904111)
>Twitter is open, a private email server is not.

In what way is Twitter "open"? Can I FOIA a government official's DM's? I don't see that as likely.

From my standpoint, Clinton's private server is equivalent to Twitter (albeit likely less well-maintained from a security perspective).

To my mind, it's wholly unacceptable for the US government to maintain secret communication platforms outside the reach of FOIA. Working to keep communications off-the-record and out of the public's hands is a betrayal of the public trust.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by Thorrez on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @03:30AM (#23905004)
>In what way is Twitter "open"?

If a Tweet is posted, journalists can see it and write articles about it. Of course this doesn't apply to DMs, they are not open. I think anonbcpolitics was ignoring DMs.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by EvanAnderson on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @05:24AM (#23905481)
I can FOIA my government's one-to-one email communication. If I can't do that w/ Twitter they shouldn't be using Twitter.

The local government I work for uses some god-awful subscription software to "archive" all their various social media interaction. I'd rather just see the government not use third-party-hosted communications systems but, grudgingly, I'll take thr "archived" social media data over nothing. The data needs to be accessible to the public, ultimately.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by Thorrez on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @06:57AM (#23905864)
Shouldn't be using Twitter at all or shouldn't be using Twitter DMs?
Re:On the Twitter Hack by anonbcpolitics on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @11:11AM (#23907415)
> I think anonbcpolitics was ignoring DMs.

Yes, because there's no evidence of anyone using DMs to govern.

We don't know if a politician uses Signal, Twitter/IG DM, or other 1:1 communication apps, we have to handle those cases when we catch them, like Hillary was caught with her private email server. If she was actually punished it may have deterred people from circumventing FOIA.

I would be directly opposed to such communication the same way I'm opposed to a private email server being used. Communicating in public tweets is entirely different though.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by EvanAnderson on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @02:27PM (#23909420)
In my jurisdiction, at least, the intent "to govern" doesn't make much of a difference in whether an item is a public record or not. My public records training would cause me to assume that Twitter DMs created or received by the government entity I work for, irrespective of their intent, are public records.

It would be nice if elected leaders at all levels of government were held to the law w/ respect to public records. I was absolutely outraged at the lack of law enforcement response for Clinton's private email server, just as I was outraged at the lack of response on the private email server that George W. Bush's administration allegedly maintained.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by anonbcpolitics on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @03:03PM (#23909788)
You focused on the wrong part, I could have left out "to govern". My point was there's no evidence of anyone using DMs, we're talking about public tweets. And there's no use talking about private communications because the scope expands from Twitter to the individual's actions (sneaking around using Signal or similar, etc.).
Re:On the Twitter Hack by EvanAnderson on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @03:51PM (#23910265)
I work in IT in local government. Even with the public records and ethics training our employees receive we still encounter plenty of times when we must advise other offices re: the public records-related concerns associated with their employees using personal phones, email, and third-party hosted services in the course of their job duties (let alone "sneaking").

I would assume that, at every level of government, significant numbers of public records are being lost to free third-party hosted services.

Re:On the Twitter Hack by sanderjd on Monday July 20, 2020 @10:52PM (#23903936)
> I don't see the government relying on it.

Ok, then a sizable portion of Schneier's article here is pointless. If it's not a national security risk, then this hack, while a big deal, is not as big a deal as he's saying.

Personally, I think it is much less of a risk than some people seem to be arguing, but much more of a risk than I'd like it to be. I do think someone could cause major real-world problems with national security ramifications by tweeting something from the President's account, and I don't think that should be possible.