Re:Plutonium is Forever
by Eliezer on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @05:25PM
(#2389317)
Because if Germany makes fewer nuclear plants, they'll make more coal plants.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Or more solar? Increase efficiency? Or use less?
False choice.
The situation in question is Merkel shutting down the 7 oldest German nuclear plants for 3 months. There will be no new clean sources of power deployed during those 3 months -- and unless there is a national campaign to reduce use starting right now in Germany, it will be mostly covered by coal.
During those 3 months, ~250 more will die to SO2 and NOx because of increased coal power production.
I'm disappointed that I was downvoted to 0 on this one. I didn't think I was overly argumentative and gave an honest response to the parent poster. I hate meta-comments, but they wouldn't be necessary if people wouldn't moderate based on personal agreement/disagreement.