Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by Udo on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:03PM
(#2389623)
I have seen that article before. From other people. Many times. The first ones were kind of interesting, but I think this meme needs to die now. I apologize if that sounds rude to you, please don't take it personally.
If I as an HN newbie may be so bold to say: what bothers me is that HN is being used as a marketing instrument. I can only speak for myself, of course, but the reason I come back here is HN feels like a medium where I'm not inundated with "viral" crap and sales pitches. For me, this place is about the exchange of ideas and honest criticism.
Don't get me wrong, one of the things I love most around here is when people show off their new projects. I think it's a great environment to do this, to get early feedback and maybe even some kind of recognition. But playing HN for the numbers of visitors feels wrong to me, and it feels cheap.
I believe the discussion inside the threads is where the real value lies. Not in the karma you get for posting the link. And certainly not in the highly irrelevant visitor count of your website.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by idlewords on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:04PM
(#2389985)
More mystifying than the fact that these 'I got linked from HN and made a graph!' articles get written is that they get routinely voted to the front page, which just perpetuates the problem.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by chaosmachine on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:43PM
(#2388842)
The more "look how many hits we got from HN" posts that get voted up, the more people will be enticed to spam/game HN.
I'd like to see a moratorium on this kind of meta-content.
As PG said: "There ought to be a word for this phenomenon where people follow a post that got them a lot of traffic from HN with another about how much traffic they got."
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by dwwoelfel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @04:01PM
(#2388929)
This article would have been much more valuable if the "look how many hits we got" served as a backdrop for an analysis of the marketing strategy they mentioned.
It's much easier to post graphs and numbers than it is to do a proper analysis of strategy, which is why we see so many of the former and so few of the latter.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by skyfallsin on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @04:04PM
(#2388952)
We thought it would be useful since a lot of new startups do wind up showing their work on HN before anyone else picks them up. We were trying to show folks what to expect, and the ramifications of getting that kind of traffic coupled with a strong viral loop.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by d2 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @04:58PM
(#2389210)
Not to be pedantic, but it's not a functioning viral loop if it dies after a few days and requires another HN or TC post. A true viral loop has exponential growth with each participant recruiting > 1 new member.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by mcdowall on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:12PM
(#2388721)
Its quite indicative of the audience here that on the top 10 browsers IE does not appear, whereas if I look at daily traffic for the health site I work on in my day job (older and significantly less techy demo) IE is the number 1, 2 and 3 browsers.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by smlacy on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @02:57PM
(#2388657)
Interesting. I hit the HN top 10 on friday, (highest rank was #5) and traffic continued on twitter (even to this day) so I can't say what the total outcome was. Because of the broader appeal of my post, I'm still seeing ongoing RT's on twitter that are driving significant traffic. Here's a snapshot of my stats so far, which doesn't (of course) include today's traffic, which is continuing at a slightly lower rate than the prior 5 days.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by redthrowaway on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:17PM
(#2390010)
I suspect most people aren't using Linux as their primary OS at home. Macs are incredibly popular with programmers, designers, and Internet types, which pretty much encapsulates the HN crowd. In my [CS] department, at least half the students and almost all of the profs use Macs.
Re:Traffic stats from a #2 post on Hacker News + Viral Loop
by albedoa on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:03PM
(#2388675)
I believe you're talking about the GMail functionality, but the Receivd team will definitely be able to see the +hn in the email address you send them. Google has nothing to do with it.
If I as an HN newbie may be so bold to say: what bothers me is that HN is being used as a marketing instrument. I can only speak for myself, of course, but the reason I come back here is HN feels like a medium where I'm not inundated with "viral" crap and sales pitches. For me, this place is about the exchange of ideas and honest criticism.
Don't get me wrong, one of the things I love most around here is when people show off their new projects. I think it's a great environment to do this, to get early feedback and maybe even some kind of recognition. But playing HN for the numbers of visitors feels wrong to me, and it feels cheap.
I believe the discussion inside the threads is where the real value lies. Not in the karma you get for posting the link. And certainly not in the highly irrelevant visitor count of your website.
I'd like to see a moratorium on this kind of meta-content.
As PG said: "There ought to be a word for this phenomenon where people follow a post that got them a lot of traffic from HN with another about how much traffic they got."
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2371252
It's much easier to post graphs and numbers than it is to do a proper analysis of strategy, which is why we see so many of the former and so few of the latter.
http://i.imgur.com/PjULs.png
I might have to use that + Analytics/Gaug.es instead of what I've been doing (which is not much).