Re:Bitcoin, a service and the micro-micro-economy
by lutorm on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:49AM
(#2387783)
Just to make it clear, while I agree with the idea of a tax-funded government, I do have issues with specific implementations of this idea, the US budget being one of them.
Your Mafia example is spurious, as it's not subject to elections. A democratic government only exists by the consent of the governed. I do not think that corporations or organized crime have taxing authority.
Re:Bitcoin, a service and the micro-micro-economy
by mike_esspe on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:21AM
(#2396325)
By that logic - you can't tax those who don't vote, because they didn't give their consent.
The basic, vital services you need (police, fire, roads, water, government administrators, etc) amount to only 24% of the government budget and a much smaller fraction of the federal budget.
http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/piechart_2009_US_total#u...
(Education and the military make up the remainder.)
I draw a line at 50%. When >50% of your taxes are simply taken and given to others, I think it's morally legitimate to evade them.
Your morality may vary. I'd be curious to know where you draw the line. Is it ok for the government to waste 75% of your tax money? Is it ok for other organizations threatening violence to do the same? I.e., is it morally legitimate to evade Mafia protection payments if they spent 50.01% on publicly beneficial services?
[1] I'm counting SS, medicare/medicaid/etc, welfare and mortgage interest deduction as "direct wealth transfers". I don't know how to allocate interest on debt, so I'm excluding that from the total. There are probably other categories of direct wealth transfers that I didn't think of.